Universal Geneve Watches On Ebay

Posts
3,480
Likes
8,076
I have my doubts about the dial and hands on that one (and the price). This one looks a little better (but I'm still not sure about the dial):

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ricambi-...automatic-28-mm/363243615527?autorefresh=true

s-l1600.jpg

I was assuming definite redial on the first one. Not sure on the black one, would have to research.
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
548
Likes
2,559
I was watching this one closely and took the plunge. A deal was a done with the seller at a much more realistic price level.
Fingers crossed that the fuzzy photographs lead to some upside surprise in the metal.


https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/203248844570

I had no choice really as I am slowly building a modest collection of Climate Proof and Colonials and they come up so rarely for sale.

I can totally understand these concerns about the hands, gentlemen;
ÌMHO definitely not correct
Thanks, that was my view also.

However, I have seen this unusual handset paired with similar Climate Proof dials before. There is a fighting chance they are correct, I think;


Credit to OF user @X350 XJR
https://omegaforums.net/threads/small-things-radium-and-beautiful.80113/page-3#post-102455
Credit to Hodinkee
https://shop.hodinkee.com/products/sedona-strap-in-ash

Having said all of that, I think there have been shenanigans with the lume on the hour and minute hands, possibly a long time ago.

In addition, the crown stem is very wobbly, the case is a bit weathered in places and the movement might look like a horrorshow under there. It is currently with my watchmaker for at least two months. If you see it pop up again here you’ll know that the gamble paid off. If not, lets never speak of this watch again 👍
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
3,480
Likes
8,076
I was watching this one closely and took the plunge. A deal was a done with the seller at a much more realistic price level.
Fingers crossed that the fuzzy photographs lead to some upside surprise in the metal.


https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/203248844570

I had no choice really as I am slowly building a modest collection of Climate Proof and Colonials and they come up so rarely for sale.

I can totally understand these concerns about the hands, gentlemen;



However, I have seen this unusual handset paired with similar Climate Proof dials before. There is a fighting chance they are correct, I think;


Credit to OF user @X350 XJR
https://omegaforums.net/threads/small-things-radium-and-beautiful.80113/page-3#post-102455
Credit to Hodinkee
https://shop.hodinkee.com/products/sedona-strap-in-ash

Having said all of that, I think there have been shenanigans with the lume on the hour and minute hands, possibly a long time ago.

In addition, the crown stem is very wobbly, the case is a bit weathered in places and the movement might look like a horrorshow under there. It is currently with my watchmaker for at least two months. If you see it pop up again here you’ll know that the gamble paid off. If not, lets never speak of this watch again 👍

congrats on building your climate proof empire. I didn't weigh in on the hands because I've definitely seen them before, but not studied enough to form an educated opinion, so I figured better not to cast a vote
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
6,283
Likes
9,842
I have seen this unusual handset paired with similar Climate Proof dials before.
I stand corrected 😒
 
Posts
6,283
Likes
9,842
No swiss?
 
Posts
865
Likes
2,371
It looks like a re-made Tri-compax dial no? Look at the concentric lines in the top sub-dial with the XII- not sure why they'd have made that indent. Maybe they got cheap and tried to re-purpose excess dials?
 
Posts
548
Likes
2,559
I assume - a redial sold today for EUR 12.000 excl 35% fee. Serial: 753553. Very strong price IMHO

Another vote for some kind of redial here.

The Roman hour numerals on the dial look imperfect to me. You can almost sense the pencil tracing lines above and below the markers.

The track inside the rolling seconds subdial at 9 o’clock is too far away from the boundary of that subdial to my eyes. Lots of other things look off. No ‘Swiss’ at six as noted by others.

Even if I’m wrong (likely) and all is well (possible) and correct (at a push) it’s still not one that sings to me.
 
Posts
3,480
Likes
8,076
It looks like a re-made Tri-compax dial no? Look at the concentric lines in the top sub-dial with the XII- not sure why they'd have made that indent. Maybe they got cheap and tried to re-purpose excess dials?

other dodicione have the upper subdial indent. I haven't studied them, or the above example, enough to form an opinion.
 
Posts
192
Likes
178
Do UG normally use IV for the numeral 4. It is the first time I have seen it, normally IIII is used.
 
Posts
94
Likes
249
IV is seen on other dodicione’s

indent at 12 yes, but with circular graining underneath?
 
Posts
163
Likes
402
Another vote for some kind of redial here.

The Roman hour numerals on the dial look imperfect to me. You can almost sense the pencil tracing lines above and below the markers.

The track inside the rolling seconds subdial at 9 o’clock is too far away from the boundary of that subdial to my eyes. Lots of other things look off. No ‘Swiss’ at six as noted by others.

Even if I’m wrong (likely) and all is well (possible) and correct (at a push) it’s still not one that sings to me.

Looking at the two dodicione dials in Sala (bw plates, page 293) I would say:
- indent is ok
- IV is ok
- no Swiss is ok (for serial around 750000 it’s normal)
To my eye the only thing visibly different from those two examples is the position of XII within the “fourth subdial”. It’s kind of too low near the center of the entire dial.
Generally it looks fine to me.
(Btw the two examples from Sala are obviously bigger than the small ref 22213 which may also explain differences in layout)

 
Posts
6,283
Likes
9,842
My Sala was not accessible but I'm back on the fence now. The placement of the XII and the (lack of) sharpness of the numbers is what still bothers me
 
Posts
94
Likes
249
The watch was at tajan paris twice before, it is within serial range of the few other datos known on here.

I think the dial is a later service dial, aside from the fonts and the placement of the text, the outer scale usually appears to be a tachy in stead of just seconds

second time: https://auction.tajan.com/fr/asp/fullCatalogue.asp?salelot=2045 96 &refno= 548429&saletype=
first time: https://auction.tajan.com/fr/asp/fullCatalogue.asp?salelot=2024 46 &refno= 548429&saletype=

as to the second number: some retailer inventory number engraved later?
Edited:
 
Posts
6,283
Likes
9,842
Thanks. Interesting reference! More info: https://omegaforums.net/threads/universal-geneve-oversized-dato-compax.90371/

Interesting that the 877.xxx serials don't seem to have numbered movements while the 1.174.xxx do have.
Edit: this one may have one: https://www.catawiki.be/l/11246473-universal-geneve-dato-compax-chronograph-men-s-watch-1944

https://mentawatches.com/product/universal-geneve-dato-compax/

 
Posts
1,044
Likes
3,782
That Dato is clearly redialed, imho.

And I still believe that, that dodicione has an original dial. Definitely a strong price for it, to be honest.