Torn between these two !!!

Posts
2,797
Likes
8,219
You got your divers covered with the SMP and the PO, so Speedy it is.
 
Posts
7,571
Likes
13,977
The Seamaster does nothing for me, I'm not a fan of big white dialled watches. I'd pick the Speedmaster every time, but with the hesalite crystal, I really don't need to see the movement.
 
Posts
1,205
Likes
7,101
A life without a Speedy is possible but... 😝
 
Posts
1,438
Likes
2,213
I love the AT -- prefer it to most SMPs as a superb all-rounder, and think it vies with the Speedy as Omega's best executed modern watch, but that dial will wear big, so I go for the Speedy here.

Agree with others that a hesalite beats the sapphire sandwich for me, although as an FOIS owner I'm not a sapphire snob. Both excellent and the Sandwich is a respected variant.
 
Posts
94
Likes
105
I'm the contrarian -- out of the watches you mention in the collection, methinks the AT would be the most versatile. Might be a good daily watch.

I'd think one of them makes your heart beat faster? If not, get them both lol
Edited:
 
Posts
27
Likes
34
I am a huge AT fan just not a fan of that particular iteration. Another Speedy vote.
 
Posts
307
Likes
444
Hi friends

I currently have a 41mm SMP and 42mm PO and may add a new piece to the collection… I am really torn between these two.. both are mint.. both are beautiful…
Aqua Terra white face
Speedmaster Professional

I know it is pure personal preference but just want to see how others see these two..

Both are pre-owned by the way
i'm going to go against the grain & recommend the AT -- you have 2 dive watches. I'm assuming the SMP 41mm is a chronograph? maybe not the version you have....
anyway, the Speedy is a super watch (said as an owner) but maybe you want variety (of functionality) in your collection which the AT will provide. Plus, a different dial color too. The AT is a sporty dress watch (if there's such a category) --- really nice looking dress watch.........
 
Posts
233
Likes
382
puh, thats a hard one!
as a speedy fan its the speedie but this AT is very nice too!
would decide after the purpose for the watch!
speedy is so versatile and fits every outfit and event!
 
Posts
246
Likes
1,253
Simple fix to your problem, pickup both of them. Now you have watches for both office, sporty and weekend!