Community Stories

Torn between some models for a first watch. Need help!

N
Posts
5
Likes
1
Hey all,

Greetings from Australia!

I have been doing bucketloads of research and still can’t decide on a watch. Terrible I know.

mom torn between the Seamaster Dive 300m.

either black or white dial on a rubber strap.

ORRRR

Speedmaster.

I got a little excited when I jumped on the Omega site and saw the Speedmaster Pro on a nylon strap for around $7k.

I thought, awesome…good price! But maybe I’ll call before going to the OB to try it on.

I call and yep, it’s the discontinued 1861 model.

Crap.

$7425 would have been great for a brand new Speedy.

The reference 311. Etc (3861 model) is $2000 more which I find to be a fscking ridiculous price increase but whatever. Nothing I can do about it.

New model is $9700 on a bracelet.

I was offered 10% off on the Seamaster on the rubber strap without even asking for a discount.

So now I’m torn.

Seamaster or Speedmaster.

I don’t need a diving watch but I don’t need a moon watch either. I just want one.

Not too keen on a second hand piece and tax on importing from Chrono24 negates any savings at all.

Help guys, can’t choose!
 
gbesq
Posts
9,739
Likes
54,481
The new 3861 movement in the Speedmaster has had some issues that have required some owners to return their watches to Omega for warranty service. Not that unusual for a new caliber, but that fact could weigh in favor of the Seamaster at this point in time.
 
Ree
Posts
445
Likes
1,283
Have you tried both on the wrist? For me these days it all comes down to how well these watches sit on the wrist.
I've bought some, unseen, that turns out to be too thick/awkward for my wrist that they end up not being worn too often.
 
rob#1
Posts
2,011
Likes
3,396
Welcome to the forum 👍

Nowt wrong with an 1861, a proven calibre. Seamasters are great watches too, depends if you want a date function or a chronograph.

Just try them on and see which one speaks to you the most.
 
N
Posts
5
Likes
1
Thanks guys.

the Seamaster looked great on but haven’t tried the Speedmaster yet.

Also, can’t find a 1861 model anywhere in store/new. Most probably becouse they don’t want to sell them for $7400 or they’re simply sold out.

I like both the date and chrono.

Seamaster does look a lot more casual/sporty. It is a hard watch to ‘dress up’.
 
Spruce
Posts
8,630
Likes
71,372
Buy a few and rotate them 😀
 
dstfno
Posts
420
Likes
490
Something to also consider is the "maintenance" required to keep your watch running.

The 300M is an automatic watch and with a very accurate movement. No winding and you will probably need to adjust the time only once per month.

The 1861 is a manual wind so you'll need to wind it daily and it's not as accurate (not even COSC certified I think). You'll need to correct the time probably at least once per week.
 
Evitzee
Posts
7,682
Likes
14,208
Don't decide on a Seamaster over a Speedmaster just because of the price. Get the watch you really want, not a substitute based on price.
 
arno
Posts
254
Likes
330
You will end owning both. Just a matter of time and of which to buy first.
 
STANDY
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
Had a speedy for 8 years and love it. Darwin based so it gets wet often.


Go the speedy and rock a Seiko for water sports until you have saved for the Seamaster also….


Such a strap champion
98F3DC03-5384-4746-80FC-65964DE6D252.jpeg 6C0342D6-ED46-48A7-9F8C-DB5168DBA46D.jpeg 57BD6ADE-1950-43C4-8B0C-ADCA8CBB1D16.jpeg CDD79AD2-635E-43B3-81F7-7292787377B7.jpeg C82051DA-4546-4900-A3F7-387D8E1A0B55.jpeg


Have a diver also that does the job up to 1000m
3B55C7C1-7DA7-4BA2-8E9A-0527EA32FA95.jpeg
Edited:
 
A
Posts
121
Likes
78
arno arno
You will end owning both. Just a matter of time and of which to buy first.
I agree with this. One usually leads to a greater love of the other
 
hen
Posts
2,979
Likes
8,738
Seamaster for sure!

Take a look at the posts in this forum, witch type has the most problems. You seldom see anyone complain about their Seamaster.
It more accurate, it has a real crystal, you can have a cup of coffe without the crystal fogging up on the inside, you dont have to wind it and its less expensive.
And its better looking😉
Edited:
 
rob#1
Posts
2,011
Likes
3,396
I’ve had plenty of cups of coffee and never ever has my crystal fogged up 😉

Generally I find it’s my brain that is fogged up before I have coffee, while the watch just ticks along regardless, and winding it is a pleasure. I do like the Seamaster, although I’d prefer it if it had sword hands and don’t really see the need for the valve ::stirthepot::.
 
N
Posts
5
Likes
1
HEV aside, I do like and prefer the fact that it's an automatic movement, crystal and not as 'common' as the Speedmaster.

Not that every Joe Blow has a Speedy but those that do have Omegas normally for the Speedmaster.

I like both but SMP might be the go.

Will try both on at the AD in a couple of weeks and decide.

Unless the Planet Ocean wins.

Has anyone managed to fit a different bracelet on their Seamaster 300M?

I prefer the rubber band or a nato strap look on that watch but wouldn't mind a bracelet, as long as it's not the one that comes with the watch. That thing is UGLY.
 
KnoP
Posts
233
Likes
382
i just can suggest a speedy. it is a strap monster and fits every outfit!
 
12 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

JimNantz

Speedmaster 3861 issues for a first time luxury watch owner

JimNantz Modern Omega Watches
JimNantz
JimNantz
Posts
36
Views
27K