I obsessed over both for quite some time! Inspired me to post my first rebus submission, so let's see how it goes.
The image forming your reply is more abstruse than the original clue. But you might have nailed it. So here is half a star. Confirm who it is in the image, and I’ll post the rest of your prize.
OK. It references Aaron Chwatt, AKA Red Buttons. (I didn't know he was Aaron Chwatt, but I fondly remember him from Hatari as John Wayne's sidekick).