Omega vs JLC - X'mas watch recommendations

Posts
50
Likes
48
As a real fan of Omega (I have had two Geneves, two Speedmasters, three Constellations and three Seamasters), I will tell you that I have recently acquired a JLC and it is in a different league. Omega makes spectacularly good watches that are also a great value proposition compared to other mass produced Swiss brands (I’m talking about you, Rolex) - durable, reliable, stylish and with cutting edge technology, particularly in the new METAS certified master chronometer models. That being said, I would not describe Omega as a brand that represents haute horology whereas JLC most certainly does. Really comes down to your personal preferences, but you can’t go wrong with either brand.
Cheers! You are right. Omega is exceptional value for money, especially in this case. I think if I pinpoint my issue, it's 60% heart, 40% brain = JLC, and 40% heart, 60% brain = Worldtimer. Since I know I won't be getting another piece for a while, I do want something that will last more on a daily wear basis. Just as a ref. point, I do have a CK2998 but no JLC.
 
Posts
9,537
Likes
52,532
Cheers! You are right. Omega is exceptional value for money, especially in this case. I think if I pinpoint my issue, it's 60% heart, 40% brain = JLC, and 40% heart, 60% brain = Worldtimer. Since I know I won't be getting another piece for a while, I do want something that will last more on a daily wear basis. Just as a ref. point, I do have a CK2998 but no JLC.
Here are photos of my daily wearer (Omega SMPc) and my dress to impress piece (JLC Master Ultra Thin Moon). Very different watches, both great.
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
Here are photos of my daily wearer (Omega SMPc) and my dress to impress piece (JLC Master Ultra Thin Moon). Very different watches, both great.
Both nice, though that JLC is stunning as a dress watch
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
Another aspect that is to consider is the service costs, Omega has an added worldtimer complication. Anyone experienced in this? A normal Omega chronograph costs roughly 1000 AUD to service here
 
Posts
1,301
Likes
2,576
You didn't say whether you've tried both on the wrist for size comparison, 39 vs 43mm I think? IMHO the JLC is more elegant, Omega more "smart casual". If you wear a business suit 5 days a week, the JLC might make more sense because it gives you another option. If you mainly wear smart casual or casual, then the Worldtimer.
 
Posts
9,537
Likes
52,532
Another aspect that is to consider is the service costs, Omega has an added worldtimer complication. Anyone experienced in this? A normal Omega chronograph costs roughly 1000 AUD to service here
On average, an Omega will cost less to service than a JLC, but with any brand the more complications on a given watch, the higher the service cost.
 
Posts
983
Likes
1,122
Thanks, but any particular reason why, please?

I have owned a lot of Omegas but not a JLC which i would like to own. Also although Omega is my favorite brand, JLC is on another level.
 
Posts
2,597
Likes
5,280
I think the World Timer may be of more practical use to you, despite the Covid. I also think the Omega would make a much more interesting addition to a collection, especially down the line.

As fine as the JLC is, the power reserve indicator only makes sense if it’s to be worn every day - probably not, as you’ve indicated that you have a varied collection.

It’s very difficult to offer a reasonable, or logical response when this kind of question is asked, especially as an opinion is being sought. The maxim here, and it’s usually a good standard, is to imagine which one would get the most wear.

Have a good one
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
You didn't say whether you've tried both on the wrist for size comparison, 39 vs 43mm I think? IMHO the JLC is more elegant, Omega more "smart casual". If you wear a business suit 5 days a week, the JLC might make more sense because it gives you another option. If you mainly wear smart casual or casual, then the Worldtimer.

More smart-casual to be honest. I have tried the Worldtimer but not this particular JLC as it's not available in any Ads / boutiques in Sydney last I checked. The 39mm would be closer home on my wrist size as I usually prefer under 40mm watches, and the worldtimer does look a bit big but has heaps of personality to it and its rather large size of 43.5mm makes it a bit different for my collection. Looks like I am inclining towards the Omega WT
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
On average, an Omega will cost less to service than a JLC, but with any brand the more complications on a given watch, the higher the service cost.
Yeah I release that, but figured maybe someone has serviced a similar JLC recently and know of the rough cost...
 
Posts
7,561
Likes
13,959
Neither one of those does much for me. For just a little more you could get the JLC Master Control Calendar, a classic triple date moonphase with thoroughly modern specs.
 
Posts
16,856
Likes
47,859
$13.5K AUD
Boutique 119 King st Sydney

 
Posts
50
Likes
48
Neither one of those does much for me. For just a little more you could get the JLC Master Control Calendar, a classic triple date moonphase with thoroughly modern specs.
This would be awesome but can't do silver/white dials. If this had a blue base, oh yeah, no doubt!
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
$13.5K AUD
Boutique 119 King st Sydney


Thanks! Now that's a beauty, for sure, but again, this is purely personal but can't do white/silver dials. Not my thing. Needs to have some colour
 
Posts
420
Likes
490
The JLC will get more wrist time now that I think about it, as wearing a worldtimer during Covid is kind of an oxymoron. We used to travel frequently before, so it made more sense. But for its price, that worldtimer not only is a stunner but very fairly priced IMHO. On the other hand, I don't have a JLC in my collection (unless I consider the movement used in another AP). Omega is more sturdy of a watch though, at least from a daily wear perspective

You don't need to travel to make use of the world timer complication. If you work with people living in other parts of the world or have family/friends there it's useful too.
 
Posts
42
Likes
53
I absolutely love the world timer! The only issue is it is a little larger than I venture into - 44 - I'd love to see some wrist shots! I actually haven't seen too many!
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
I absolutely love the world timer! The only issue is it is a little larger than I venture into - 44 - I'd love to see some wrist shots! I actually haven't seen too many!
It is large but the way the lugs are designed doesn't feel too big on the wrist. Here's a photo of it on my 6.5-inch wrist for reference
 
Posts
50
Likes
48
You don't need to travel to make use of the world timer complication. If you work with people living in other parts of the world or have family/friends there it's useful too.
It would be useful for work, that's true
 
Posts
1,071
Likes
2,165
They both have their downsides. The World Timer doesn't instantly teleport you to the timezone of your choice, but the power reserve on the JLC doesn't directly correlate to YOUR power.

But seriously, I don't think there's anything particularly unique about JLC, so between those two I'd choose the WT. But as others have pointed out, there are other choices and a duoface reverso would be a cracking one.