Oyster Perpetual 39mm or Aqua Terra 41mm?

Posts
2,808
Likes
8,338
Ah, I was thinking about getting the DJ41 but to be honest, I can't stand the cyclops date window or any Arabic numerals on the dial; hence why I dismissed the submariner, DJ's and explorers.

My only option is thus the OP as it's the most basic Rolex; I just want a dependable and versatile timepiece that'll give me as much happiness years from now as it did when I bought it.

Sounds like my recommendation is the one you'll going with then 馃憤
 
Posts
437
Likes
346
Sounds like my recommendation is the one you'll going with then 馃憤

Indeed it does.

Thank you everyone for your opinions, I truly appreciate each and every one of them.
So I have the choice of either a white dial OP or black dial OP. I figure that even though I love Omega it wouldn't hurt to take the Rolex for a spin.

Worst comes to worst I could just sell the OP and buy the AT, if I buy the AT and wanted to get the OP I wouldn't be able to get all my money back.

Now I have to ask if I should go for the white dial or black dial OP?
I had a think and thought that although the white is the most classic and timeless it just looks like more of a mature timepiece than the black.

Maybe this should now be in the Rolex section?
Edited:
 
Posts
2,808
Likes
8,338
Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial Black Dial

While many say to pick a white dial in a vintage thin dress watch, the black dial in the Oyster-cased sports watch looks classy with subdued elegance and refinement. The white dial with those black hands in this model makes it look cheap, to me. The while dial black hands is much better in something like an Explorer II - sporty and fun. But you want a boardroom to beach watch.
 
Posts
6,832
Likes
13,793
Both great, I personally went with the white Datejust. If it was the blue AT versus OP Blue I'd go AT but on white I like the Rolex better.

Both can be work on steel or bracelet. Buy them on steel as it is much more expensive to buy a bracelet that it is to find a good strap.

Best of luck,

S
 
Posts
1,019
Likes
1,018
On the other side I love the Omega lugs

My vote will always be for an omega for this reason. However the OP is a great choice and I would love one as well. Only downside to the AT in my opinion is the size. 41 is a little on the big side to be really dressy.

Obviously there are factors in play which only you can consider su h as your normal attire and wrist size. Goodluck Both look great.
 
Posts
886
Likes
469
The watches are so different in that one is on a strap and the other a bracelet with a different case shape and hands.
The only real comparitive feature between them is the dial colour.

All I can offer is that if it's so hard to choose between them and seeing as they're both relatively available is to defer making a commitment either way until one or the other sings to your heart.

Personally, if you were looking at the previous generation of AT with the vertical stripes it would be a no brainer to go for the Omega.
As you are looking at the current AT, then I would probably choose the Rolex as I consider it to be a better watch. Then perhaps look at changing the bracelet for a strap of my choosing if required and keeping the bracelet safely stored in the box.

Why aren't you considering the DJ 41?
 
Posts
236
Likes
289
D Duckie
The watches are so different in that one is on a strap and the other a bracelet with a different case shape and hands.
The only real comparitive feature between them is the dial colour.

All I can offer is that if it's so hard to choose between them and seeing as they're both relatively available is to defer making a commitment either way until one or the other sings to your heart.

Personally, if you were looking at the previous generation of AT with the vertical stripes it would be a no brainer to go for the Omega.
As you are looking at the current AT, then I would probably choose the Rolex as I consider it to be a better watch. Then perhaps look at changing the bracelet for a strap of my choosing if required and keeping the bracelet safely stored in the box.

Why aren't you considering the DJ 41?

Or even the one before in 39mm... My choice! 馃槣

779cf28a-8356-4119-8wwjd9.jpeg
 
Posts
437
Likes
346
D Duckie
The watches are so different in that one is on a strap and the other a bracelet with a different case shape and hands.
The only real comparitive feature between them is the dial colour.

All I can offer is that if it's so hard to choose between them and seeing as they're both relatively available is to defer making a commitment either way until one or the other sings to your heart.

Personally, if you were looking at the previous generation of AT with the vertical stripes it would be a no brainer to go for the Omega.
As you are looking at the current AT, then I would probably choose the Rolex as I consider it to be a better watch. Then perhaps look at changing the bracelet for a strap of my choosing if required and keeping the bracelet safely stored in the box.

Why aren't you considering the DJ 41?

They're the timepieces that I've shortlisted, meeting all of my requirements at a very similar price point. I could always spend more but I'm looking at necessities rather than desires.

The DJ41 has that horrific cyclops date which as I said is something I'm not too fond of. Features such as the cyclops, arabic/roman numerals and sub-dials aren't something that I'm looking for in an everyday watch.

I want something simple, legible and functional that'll blend in wherever I go and essentially be in my collection for the long-term.

Concerning the bracelet switch I asked a boutique in London and they mentioned they couldn't offer the oysterflex as "Rolex were protecting their brand" and thus all watches must be on their original strap otherwise at service time they'll destroy the aftermarket and replace it with a bracelet at my expense...
I mean I don't mind switching back to bracelet at service time but I didn't expect such a strict policy on something like strap changes.
Edited:
 
Posts
1,019
Likes
1,018
I want something simple, legible and functional that'll blend in wherever I go

2504.52 馃槜馃槜馃槜

I may be biased however 馃槈
 
Posts
1,099
Likes
1,081
the omega is a sharper looking watch that the op you posted.

that said. i really like a few of the op's.,....but i just don't like the one you pictured that much

i would look into the 3/6/9 dials as well. for an entry level rolex these have nice design elements.

m114300-0003.png
 
Posts
27
Likes
116
I definitely like the Omega better. It's sportier. However, having owned a Rolex Explorer 1 (36mm) several years ago, I can say I do love the Oyster Perpetual design and I think the Rolex - arguably more boring - may survive the test of time better.
 
Posts
437
Likes
346
the omega is a sharper looking watch that the op you posted.

That said, I really like a few of the op's... But I just don't like the one you pictured that much

i would look into the 3/6/9 dials as well. for an entry level rolex these have nice design elements.

m114300-0003.png

Indeed I did think about some of the other OP's but I prefer full lumed dials. Plus apparently the movements been improved in the new black/white OP's so I'm sticking with them.

I understand the white OP does look kind of dated, I didn't realise there was a black dial option until today!

Definitely black dial!

I'm leaning towards the black dial actually, possibly in part due to Larry's persuasive statement but it actually is something I can imagine wearing for life and being proud of purchasing.
Edited:
 
Posts
62
Likes
115
I'd definitely prefer the Seamaster between the two.

I'm biased, but I agree. AT all the way.

Maybe other Omega advantages to consider too:

- Anti-magnetic
-60 vs. 20hr power reserve
-Timezone hour jump when adjusting
-Window caseback
-Omega brand strap availability
-Silicon Escapement (less-frequent maintenance)

I don't love steel bracelets either, but Omega makes tons of Nato, Leather, & Cordura straps that look great with the aqua terra. This is much harder to find with the OP.
 
Posts
429
Likes
604
I'm confident, just not confident enough to strut around in a rubber suit; seriously wearing one must be super uncomfortable!

I was thinking to go for the Oysterflex strap or a Rolex leather strap. Truth be told bracelets aren't my favourite, although if I had to wear any bracelet it would be a Rolex bracelet.

Thank you all for your opinions so far, I'm also leaning more towards the OP but I've just realised they sell it in black so that's also something to consider..
I like the OP, but I'd go with an Explorer 1 for a little more money. The OP is just a tad too plain for me.
 
Posts
437
Likes
346
UPDATE:

So after deciding to buy the OP, I strut into the local Rolex Boutique looking for the black dial OP 39. Unfortunately they, or any Rolex dealers in London for that matter didn't have a single piece in stock; thus I ask to be notified when one comes in.

I got the call 2 weeks ago and was seriously excited to finally get the chance to buy one.
Guess what I saw when I checked out the OP display?

They thought I had been referring to the white dial OP rather than the black dial I was after (despite stressing the fact that I didn't want the white dial at the time). The person who took down my request adamantly denied that I asked for the black dial and that I was mistaken. We chalked it down to miscommunication in the end. Another OP 39mm would take at least a month.

After looking over the boutique, only seeing PM day-dates laden with diamonds and listening to the SA rambling about how Rolex was the best; I decided enough was enough and walked out, never to return.

I knew it wouldn't be easy/quick getting a Rolex, but if that's how it works then I'll be happy to stick with Omega.
 
Posts
1,613
Likes
5,066
Well, that's a disappointing outcome. But not altogether surprising, from what I understand.

I bought my stainless steel Submariner nearly five years ago, when you could still find them easily in display cases at every Rolex AD. I've found myself wearing it less the more expensive and hard to find they become. The fact that the SA got snippy isn't a good sign, but I don't think you'll find the same thing at an Omega Boutique or AD. The AT you've been considering is readily available, and buying it will be much more fun than getting a Rolex, under current circumstances.
 
Posts
142
Likes
357
Head to an Omega boutique and try on every reference of AT 41mm that they have and make a few hours out of it. Much more fun than the empty Rolex case.