Need help to confirm authenticity of Pie pan

Posts
1,790
Likes
2,001
I'm still torn cause the dial is good so far.
It would get some compliments, from non Omega fans. 80% of what you see is the dial, & this dial is spectacular.
The dial will appreciate in value, the case is worth gold value.
As already mentioned, if you wanted a wearer, for under $1000 this has some value. Factor in a service cost, too.
 
Posts
16
Likes
5
What do you guys think of this watch? Should there be a 'T' after the 'Swiss Made'? It's serial number is in the 20Million.
 
Posts
2,337
Likes
6,707
Here's my 167.005 - no "T". Serial 19,3 M
Crown is decagonal

 
Posts
12,773
Likes
17,333
What do you guys think of this watch? Should there be a 'T' after the 'Swiss Made'?
Yes, the “T” is correct. Watch is from around 1963.

Tritium on hands is gone. Case looks pretty beat up although movement looks decent. You will always need a watchmaker to inspect a vintage watch. You cannot tell from a picture what service has it has not been done.

I would not pay a lot for this watch as you are going to need new (re-lumed) hands and probably a service.

The second watch you posted is a totally different watch. It is from the mid-1970’s and was only sold in the Far East. It used to be very rare, but more and more have been spotted lately as dealers from that area have been translating listings to English and selling on eBay. It is smaller and thinner than the 1960’s versions. I own one of each.

What are asking prices?
gatorcpa
 
Posts
16
Likes
5
Yes, the “T” is correct. Watch is from around 1963.

Tritium on hands is gone. Case looks pretty beat up although movement looks decent. You will always need a watchmaker to inspect a vintage watch. You cannot tell from a picture what service has it has not been done.

I would not pay a lot for this watch as you are going to need new (re-lumed) hands and probably a service.

The second watch you posted is a totally different watch. It is from the mid-1970’s and was only sold in the Far East. It used to be very rare, but more and more have been spotted lately as dealers from that area have been translating listings to English and selling on eBay. It is smaller and thinner than the 1960’s versions. I own one of each.

What are asking prices?
gatorcpa
I'm not sure of the price of the first watch yet but the second one is below $1200. What's a fair price for each one? I don't know that the second will be smaller. I thought both are 34mm?
 
Posts
12,773
Likes
17,333
I the diameter of both are about the same.

The steel (and it only comes in steel) 1970’s version is not as big from lug tip to lug tip. It is also a couple of mm thinner. The “pie-pan” effect is much flatter on the dial and is accomplished by texture, rather than height. You really can’t see that in a photo. I think $1,200 is a bit high for that watch. I’d think more like high hundreds at this point.

The 1960’s dial is truly a 3D effect, where the dial is “folded” on each facet. The movements on these is considered one of the best automatics ever made.

Hope this helps,
gatorcpa
 
Posts
16
Likes
5
I the diameter of both are about the same.

The steel (and it only comes in steel) 1970’s version is not as big from lug tip to lug tip. It is also a couple of mm thinner. The “pie-pan” effect is much flatter on the dial and is accomplished by texture, rather than height. You really can’t see that in a photo. I think $1,200 is a bit high for that watch. I’d think more like high hundreds at this point.

The 1960’s dial is truly a 3D effect, where the dial is “folded” on each facet. The movements on these is considered one of the best automatics ever made.

Hope this helps,
gatorcpa
Thanks, that's very insightful! Now that you mention it, I realized the second watch has flatter dial. Wouldn't have known this otherwise.I'll pass on this then.

As for the first watch, what's a good price for it?
 
Posts
12,773
Likes
17,333
First watch looks like a $500 to $750 piece to me. Remember that you are going to have to spend anywhere from $200 to $400 for a service and new hands. If it doesn't have an Omega signed crystal, than may be another $100 or so.

If you can keep total spend <$1,000, you will have done well.

Just remember that this is an average condition piece. It still does not have the sharp edges that collectors covet. Better condition will cost more.
gatorcpa
 
Posts
16
Likes
5
Oh wow. Didn't expect it to be that low. I've a feeling the seller wants more, at least 1k
 
Posts
13,441
Likes
31,612
Oh wow. Didn't expect it to be that low. I've a feeling the seller wants more, at least 1k

Most sellers like to equate pie-pan with big $$$, choosing to ignore the overall condition.
 
Posts
5,712
Likes
8,868
The steel (and it only comes in steel) 1970’s version is not as big from lug tip to lug tip. It is also a couple of mm thinner. The “pie-pan” effect is much flatter on the dial and is accomplished by texture, rather than height. You really can’t see that in a photo. I think $1,200 is a bit high for that watch. I’d think more like high hundreds at this point.

I suspect the market has moved for these since a few of them have been turning up regularly of late.
Buyers (not necessarily collectors) seem to equate these with ‘original’ pie pans.

The case on this one looks pretty good - although the movt does look a little tired and has some serious rotor rub.
I’m not surprised the asking is $1,200 wouldn’t expect to find one like this for less than a grand nowadays.
 
Posts
12,773
Likes
17,333
Only thing wrong is crown. Best of the lot so far and worth more than quotes given on the others.
gatorcpa
 
Posts
2,337
Likes
6,707
Only thing wrong is crown. Best of the lot so far and worth more than quotes given on the others.
gatorcpa

It also has inlaid markers! 👍
 
Posts
5,712
Likes
8,868
Another nice dial but I’m a bit concerned about the lugs.
The five o’clock lug looks pretty good but the one and seven o’clock lugs not so much.
It could be just the light but the rounding of the lugs suggests either heavy use or polishing (either way they don’t look sharp)
Better pictures needed to offer a more definitive critique.
 
Posts
1,258
Likes
2,728
Dial is original but the case is -like other members have already pointed out- polished way too much. It has the “melted” look. See below my steel pie pan with very sharp dog leg case so you can see the difference, see the facets on the lugs:
Nothing beats a sharp dog leg case. Mine says hi