Community Stories

Is this watch real or fake thread - aka Fake Busters!!

invocaris
Posts
15
Likes
1
Since it was a phone app, I didn't check but two positions. But I checked closely against the atomic clock in Colorado, and it's running +5 seconds/day.
 
invocaris
Posts
15
Likes
1
Thanks, Fiberguy! Any opinions on the rather high beat error of 1.0-0.3 (taking into account it was measured with a phone app)?
 
fiberguy
Posts
686
Likes
1,932
invocaris invocaris
Thanks, Fiberguy! Any opinions on the rather high beat error of 1.0-0.3 (taking into account it was measured with a phone app)?
Frankly, I know little about beat error, but I do think it would be unwise to trust a phone app to give an accurate beat error rate especially on a watch with a co-axial movement. I think you might be looking for problems where there really are none. If you are happy with the watch condition and the price you paid, I would wear it and enjoy. Its a mechanical watch its going to need service at some point, especially if it did not have a full service prior to you purchasing it.
 
invocaris
Posts
15
Likes
1
Sounds prudent. I purchased it brand new, so I'm not that concerned about an imminent servicing (although I don't know how long it's been sitting on a shelf). Very happy with my first Omega; just concerned about authenticity. I'm probably inordinately concerned. MS-TR Japan has a solid reputation according to my research.
 
ErichPryde
Posts
2,788
Likes
5,216
invocaris invocaris
Since it was a phone app, I didn't check but two positions. But I checked closely against the atomic clock in Colorado, and it's running +5 seconds/day.

You can test all 6 positions with a phone app, and get a ballpark idea of which positions run what. If there's a slower position or one that loses time you can rest your watch in that position at night if the +5 accuracy bothers you.

I wouldn't trust or worry about the beat error as measured by your phone.
Edited:
 
ErichPryde
Posts
2,788
Likes
5,216
invocaris invocaris
Thanks for good advice...very kind!

No problem. Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your watch!
 
Heinz83
Posts
256
Likes
3,561
May I ask for your opinion on this 1957 trilogy Railmaster?

The price looks very attractive at 3900 CHF for “buy now” and auction starting price 3500 CHF (too good to be true?) The seller has 1 review on the platform and only as buyer.

Any alarm bells ringing? Or do you think this watch is all good?
 
42F003EF-8A90-4C10-ADF0-936280FD6808.jpeg 207349F8-AC51-43E9-9312-CE9DAF6FAAE1.jpeg 1E894C7E-7FBC-4E5A-BFA7-76ACBBEA105F.jpeg 4FD3EAC3-1183-4EBA-B421-82CFA2C46974.jpeg
Ron_W
Posts
976
Likes
1,878
This Railmaster does not come up on ebay, do you have a link ?
At 3900 it is way cheaper then average and with a no history seller, probably a scam.
 
Ron_W
Posts
976
Likes
1,878
Thanks ! If the watch is correct you have a super deal but dont bring cash !!
An immidiate bank transfer when you have checked the watch in person will work just fine, in a place with camera`s such as hotel lobby/jewelry shop.
 
Ron_W
Posts
976
Likes
1,878
Heinz83 Heinz83
Does the watch itself look good to you?

Yes, but it was a few years ago i handled one in person so i hope one of the current owners here will help.
 
W
Posts
1
Likes
0
Please could somebody help me ID this watch? Buying from a private reseller and awaiting confirmation of paperwork.
I’m told it’s 24mm with a pink dial , however, I can’t find any similar models on Google. Might be an older model?
 
80e03610-6a5e-455b-956e-03d0c0cc2587.jpeg 1fb45406-70ec-4580-8cb6-a215faf97249.jpeg
L
Posts
9
Likes
0
I recently bought this Omega (reference 3513.33). The gentleman who sold it to me said he believes the movement to be fake because of the finishing and the blue screws, but the case is genuine.

I popped the case-back off and when I compare the markings with examples I see on chrono/eBay it looks consistent (175 0083 and 375 0083).

I need help determining if the movement is authentic and the case as well so I know whether or not to spend any money restoring this watch. Please see pics below:

https://ibb.co/FqCsfJM
https://ibb.co/98hdFgg
https://ibb.co/WxjJCr0
https://ibb.co/2MJ3Xc5
https://ibb.co/7GxCY8c
https://ibb.co/bsxmHjH
 
redpcar
Posts
3,901
Likes
8,745
L ltkalk
I recently bought this Omega (reference 3513.33). The gentleman who sold it to me said he believes the movement to be fake because of the finishing and the blue screws, but the case is genuine.

I popped the case-back off and when I compare the markings with examples I see on chrono/eBay it looks consistent (175 0083 and 375 0083).

I need help determining if the movement is authentic and the case as well so I know whether or not to spend any money restoring this watch. Please see pics below:

https://ibb.co/FqCsfJM
https://ibb.co/98hdFgg
https://ibb.co/WxjJCr0
https://ibb.co/2MJ3Xc5
https://ibb.co/7GxCY8c
https://ibb.co/bsxmHjH
upload_2023-6-19_13-57-31.png upload_2023-6-19_13-58-9.png upload_2023-6-19_13-58-47.png upload_2023-6-19_13-59-22.png upload_2023-6-19_14-2-7.png
 
313 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

ipotvin

Is this watch real or fake

ipotvin Modern Omega Watches
Donn Chambers
Donn Chambers
Posts
9
Views
2K
K

Is this Watch real of fake?

koulourio Modern Omega Watches
Ueki13
Ueki13
Posts
30
Views
6K
K

Help needed. Is this real or fake Omega De Ville?

Katarnak Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
K
Katarnak
Posts
0
Views
3K
A

Help Identify omega watch REAL or FAKE ! - ty

alexrobv Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
JimInOz
JimInOz
Posts
6
Views
3K
M

Is this a real or fake Omega Vintage watch?

Maaadi124 Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Fallout Boy
Fallout Boy
Posts
14
Views
3K
F

Just bought the vintage Geneve omega watch is it real or fake?

forecest Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Davidt
Davidt
Posts
4
Views
3K