Getting very high servicing quotes for my 60s seamaster

I think the recommendation was to expand your search beyond NYC. I have never heard anything particularly good about any NYC watchmakers, and apparently they are overpriced. I have purchased two watches that had been recently serviced by Grand Central Watch (with their fancy documentation, photos, etc.), and both were a mess, and needed to be repaired / serviced again by my watchmaker.

I know that New Yorkers think that NYC is the center of the universe and everything can be found there. But it's not always the case. It will cost you $25 to ship it by priority mail.

In my experience, collectors are protective of their watchmakers and can be reluctant to disclose contact info on searchable Internet forums. The last thing I would want is some jackass contacting my watchmaker saying that Dan S referred them. If I am interested in getting names of watchmakers, I contact people by private message or ask them in person. Networking with other collectors/enthusiasts is one of the best ways to get firsthand referrals.

Does the $1k quote include providing a bezel and fixing the hole chewed through the one lug? Seems like those items could add a bit.

Indeed what exactly is the scope of work? Seems very high.

I'm also in NYC. I send my watches out of state to get serviced because it's cheaper. I sent the last three vintage watches to Andy Lewis at Ultra Vintage in Ohio and they all came back great. Servicing ranges from $350-$400 depending on the watch so it's much more reasonable. There is a wait but that's for everyone. Just ask him how long it'll take.

https://www.ultra-vintage.com/

Before


After