A pretentious, snobby, old fashioned guide to choosing a strap

Posts
743
Likes
2,536
Oh yeah? Well ... how well do you do on pocket watch straps?

1897 solid silver Waltham with blue DaveK Mystery Braid lanyard.

1926 gold filled Illinois Sangamo Special with brown DaveK Mystery Braid lanyard.

Did you lube the movement with whale oil? If yes, use buffalo hide. If not, you're a fraud.
 
Posts
2,056
Likes
4,180
Grade: F
Normally you'd get an F for putting leather on a diver, but since that thing is not even waterproof, you instead get an F for wearing a broken watch.

How did you know the date flips at 8pm? Lol
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,917
Grade: F
Normally you'd get an F for putting leather on a diver, but since that thing is not even waterproof, you instead get an F for wearing a broken watch.
Hey- that is the watch that Rolex copied to make the Kermit!
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,792
Did you lube the movement with whale oil? If yes, use buffalo hide. If not, you're a fraud.
I wonder how many people of my age (that's less than 60) have actually seen/used instrument oil source from whales?
 
Posts
1,953
Likes
3,929
Coming back for extra credit trying to up my grade (like my kids are so good at)
Here are the initial submissions and the followup attempt at improvement:

Initial strap vintage pigskin


new strap dark brown calfskin


Initial strap tan calfskin too casual


New submission Cognac Croc!! (as suggested)


looking to boost the GPA!!!
 
Posts
652
Likes
7,366
Grade: F
Shell Cordovan is a special leather from under the rear hide of a horse. It sounds fancy, but it's aesthetically boring, being completely smooth and unremarkable. Straps made from it tend to be too thick, making it especially ill-suited for small watches, like your Alpina. Worse, that strap is not even tapered.

your "F" gets an "F".
30mm case, 1.6mm thin strap, 5/8" at lug and buckle as most 5/8" straps were bitd.
guess you missed a class 😉

 
Posts
743
Likes
2,536
Coming back for extra credit trying to up my grade (like my kids are so good at)
Here are the initial submissions and the followup attempt at improvement:

Initial strap vintage pigskin


new strap dark brown calfskin


Initial strap tan calfskin too casual


New submission Cognac Croc!! (as suggested)


looking to boost the GPA!!!

Grade: A
Bravo, sir. You're a gentleman and a scholar.
 
Posts
743
Likes
2,536
your "F" gets an "F".
30mm case, 1.6mm thin strap, 5/8" at lug and buckle as most 5/8" straps were bitd.
guess you missed a class 😉


Your F of my F gets an F. My comments were about the strap on your Alpina, not your Mido. You've mixed metric and imperial measurements, and pointed out that your strap is indeed not tapered, which it should be, unless that happens to be the original buckle.
 
Posts
743
Likes
2,536

Well you've posted a bracelet on a thread about straps, so your reading comprehension score is a D.
That does look fantastic though
 
Posts
652
Likes
7,366
Your F of my F gets an F. My comments were about the strap on your Alpina, not your Mido. You've mixed metric and imperial measurements, and pointed out that your strap is indeed not tapered, which it should be, unless that happens to be the original buckle.

oh you definitely skipped or flunked Vintage 101 😁
the vast majority of mens 5/8" straps were not tapered.
11/16"? yes, definitely, straight in that size was a rarity way back when, and aren't suited to the oldies.

Edited:
 
Posts
652
Likes
7,366
Well you've posted a bracelet on a thread about straps, so your reading comprehension score is a D.
That does look fantastic though

thanks, but tbf some of my friends outside of the US call pretty much every watch attachment a strap...or sometimes a belt...i suppose "belt" could describe some of the 2-stitch straps some of us...love
 
Posts
7,612
Likes
21,831
your "F" gets an "F".
30mm case, 1.6mm thin strap, 5/8" at lug and buckle as most 5/8" straps were bitd.
guess you missed a class 😉


Lovely watch -and buckle 👍 but what does “bitd” mean?
Careful @bradurani you’re taking on a true strap expert!
 
Posts
652
Likes
7,366
Lovely watch -and buckle 👍 but what does “bitd” mean?
Careful @bradurani you’re taking on a true strap expert!

Back In The Day
Edited:
 
Posts
652
Likes
7,366
okie i'll take another shot with the shell cordovan.
how about this match:
29mm case
1.4mm shell cordovan "slip-thru with pad"
 
Posts
5,171
Likes
46,989
"Proper" in every sense, other than the fact that this Nile Crocodile leather is banned in many parts of the civilized world...



...cow something, definitely a grey area...but I love it for casual wear...especially since I don't report to an office anymore (Yay, Pandemic) and there are only so many opportunities for weddings, funerals, bar-mitzvahs, bat-mitzvahs, christenings, Nobel award ceremonies etc.



...and possibly the most egregious...genuine ostrich, wich I love for travel -- and this is a great travel watch...



...and finally, this one, from my last cattle drive 😀
 
Posts
2,056
Likes
4,180
okie i'll take another shot with the shell cordovan.
how about this match:
29mm case
1.4mm shell cordovan "slip-thru with pad"

Oh damn, I hope you don't have that listed on ebay or it's not gonna last long now! Which reminds me to hit your store later for a new one for my new Breitling chrono. 😀