6 month Omega dial Cracked

Posts
27,915
Likes
71,095
That's exactly what I mean.
True Omega hardcore fans (reputable watchmaker as well)

Well, let's just say that I've seen a lot of crystals, and to me that one still appears to have a crack in it. That would make much more sense than a spontaneous crack appearing for no reason in the dial. I've seen nothing in Omega's extensive documentation that indicates cracked ceramic dials are a thing that just happens out of the blue.

Omega policies are to rule in favour of the watch owner, unless there are obvious signs of damage or abuse. If they find that is a crack, the OP will have to pay for it I suspect, but if not and it is a reflection (a very odd one) then it will be replaced under warranty.

I have dealt with a lot of watches that were sent to me with damage, where the person sending the watch swears that nothing happened to it. Here's one example - some years ago I bought up vintage Hamilton pocket watch movements from eBay (cases had been scrapped for the gold and the movements sold on line) and I had custom cases and dials for them, and made wrist watches out of them. Since these were vintage, the balances had no shock protect, so no Incabloc or other. This meant that the balances were quite prone to being broken by a shock, and I warned each customer of this.

I received one back from a customer in Australia who swore up and down that the watch had never received a shock, but the balance staff was broken. When I got the watch in, I saw this:



Once I pointed this out to him, he was fine with paying for the repair. I don't believe for a minute that he was trying to deceive me, but people sometimes just don't recognize at the time that something has happened. Given the position of this dent, it is likely he knocked it going through a doorway - hard enough to dent the stainless steel, and also snap the balance staff.

So you accusing people here of blaming the OP is ridiculous. I find your comments to be in poor taste, and going from memory it's not the first time either. I'll just say this - I work on Omegas nearly every day, and trust me I see all the good and bad that comes from this brand, as well as many other brands out there. You are certainly free to believe what you wish, but being a butthole to people here is taking it a bit too far mate. Get stuffed.
 
Posts
5,298
Likes
18,387
..I have dealt with a lot of watches that were sent to me with damage, where the person sending the watch swears that nothing happened to it. ..

I received one back from a customer in Australia who swore up and down that the watch had never received a shock, but the balance staff was broken.

I have cut myself many, many times and not known it.

Someone, mostly my spouse, will say "You're bleeding, what happened?"

Me: "Huh, where? Oh, thanks, I didn't see that."

How is this remotely possible. I don't know. I think it's because I have worked in carpentry and factory work and home projects for years and get focused on the work without noticing knicks, scratches, cuts.

I 100% believe people don't realize they knocked their watch about.
 
Posts
27,915
Likes
71,095
I have cut myself many, many times and not known it.

Me too - look down, see blood, and have to figure out where I have sprung a leak from...
 
Posts
654
Likes
1,031
Well, let's just say that I've seen a lot of crystals, and to me that one still appears to have a crack in it. That would make much more sense than a spontaneous crack appearing for no reason in the dial. I've seen nothing in Omega's extensive documentation that indicates cracked ceramic dials are a thing that just happens out of the blue.

Omega policies are to rule in favour of the watch owner, unless there are obvious signs of damage or abuse. If they find that is a crack, the OP will have to pay for it I suspect, but if not and it is a reflection (a very odd one) then it will be replaced under warranty.

I have dealt with a lot of watches that were sent to me with damage, where the person sending the watch swears that nothing happened to it. Here's one example - some years ago I bought up vintage Hamilton pocket watch movements from eBay (cases had been scrapped for the gold and the movements sold on line) and I had custom cases and dials for them, and made wrist watches out of them. Since these were vintage, the balances had no shock protect, so no Incabloc or other. This meant that the balances were quite prone to being broken by a shock, and I warned each customer of this.

I received one back from a customer in Australia who swore up and down that the watch had never received a shock, but the balance staff was broken. When I got the watch in, I saw this:



Once I pointed this out to him, he was fine with paying for the repair. I don't believe for a minute that he was trying to deceive me, but people sometimes just don't recognize at the time that something has happened. Given the position of this dent, it is likely he knocked it going through a doorway - hard enough to dent the stainless steel, and also snap the balance staff.

So you accusing people here of blaming the OP is ridiculous. I find your comments to be in poor taste, and going from memory it's not the first time either. I'll just say this - I work on Omegas nearly every day, and trust me I see all the good and bad that comes from this brand, as well as many other brands out there. You are certainly free to believe what you wish, but being a butthole to people here is taking it a bit too far mate. Get stuffed.
I hope your memory regarding my interventions in this forum is better than when you said before you've never seen any case like this (just to find your posts in a similar thread quoted minutes later).
https://omegaforums.net/threads/seamaster-diver-300m-cracked-ceramic-dial.154358/#post-2115341

If that happened with a Hamilton, and others tried to deceived you before, must indicate the same for sure with this particular one.
Thanks for your well detailed Hamilton analogy, and get stuffed too.
Edited:
 
Posts
27,915
Likes
71,095
If that happened with a Hamilton, and you've been deceived before must be the same for sure.

The fact you believe anyone was deceived tells me that you have completely missed the point, but that doesn't surprise me.
 
Posts
6,526
Likes
26,482
sent it to the service center. They will review and let me know if it can be fixed before I leave for the states. Keeping my fingers crossed.
A couple months later… I wonder if the OP will return and let us know if this turned out to be an out of pocket expense or was covered under warranty.
 
Posts
301
Likes
300
I zoomed in a whole bunch and still don't see it as a crack, it looks very much like a reflection off the edge of the crystal of some light source off to that side, consistent with the light reflection on the bezel. That said, I'm really curious to see what Omega did!

One thing to note: Ceramic as a material is REALLY brittle and really difficult to make without internal stresses, and you can't really temper them out. Changes in temperature or humidity (like, say, going to the hot/dry middle east!) can cause these to break. My experience is with other ceramic products (not watches obviously, mostly manufacturing fixtures for silicon), but the material is consistent even at the larger thicknesses of a watch dial.

While I'm sure Omega is near-perfect with their QA and dial construction, I wouldn't doubt that a handful of the millions of watches they make a year could have this problem. I would presume most to fail 'quickly' and get caught by the AD, but depending on the severity of the stresses, it could take quite a thermal/whatever shock to cause it.
 
Posts
8
Likes
23
Hey Everyone, wanted to give you an update. I finally got my watch dial replaced through warranty. As you know, i was travelling in Dubai at the time i noticed the crack. I gave it to an AD in dubai through a family member. They assessed the watch and did not find any major impact on the body or the crystal. But they removed the dial and sent the dial only to Omega Switzerland for analysis and replacement.I gave the watch in on December 15th 2023 and got it back (in Dubai) on Feb 14th. My parents just brought the watch back to me yesterday in the US. And it looks great. They replaced the dial and i do not see an damage on the crystal either. Just some minor scuffs on the body. (Sorry about the smudges on the watch, haha)
 
Posts
3,056
Likes
5,943
Welcome back and thank you for the update, glad to hear that you had a successful and positive resolution in this case! That's great.

Enjoy and wear in health!
 
Posts
392
Likes
498
Looks great. Always nice to read a happy outcome regarding warranty issues.
 
Posts
654
Likes
1,031
Hey Everyone, wanted to give you an update. I finally got my watch dial replaced through warranty. As you know, i was travelling in Dubai at the time i noticed the crack. I gave it to an AD in dubai through a family member. They assessed the watch and did not find any major impact on the body or the crystal. But they removed the dial and sent the dial only to Omega Switzerland for analysis and replacement.I gave the watch in on December 15th 2023 and got it back (in Dubai) on Feb 14th. My parents just brought the watch back to me yesterday in the US. And it looks great. They replaced the dial and i do not see an damage on the crystal either. Just some minor scuffs on the body. (Sorry about the smudges on the watch, haha)
Glad to hear the updating.
So no impacts at all, contrasted through the AD, despite what has been stated as granted (or highly likely at least) in this thread according to the reflection of a picture.
 
Posts
5,246
Likes
24,178
Glad to hear the updating.
So no impacts at all, contrasted through the AD, despite what has been stated as granted (or highly likely at least) in this thread according to the reflection of a picture.
The shipping of the dial itself is also baffling, how many times have we heard of the stuck clasp issue whereby the watch needed to be sent back instead of the bracelet itself.
 
Posts
27,915
Likes
71,095
The shipping of the dial itself is also baffling, how many times have we heard of the stuck clasp issue whereby the watch needed to be sent back instead of the bracelet itself.

IMO the chances of Omega replacing this dial under warranty, without first seeing the whole watch, is low...
 
Posts
8
Likes
23
IMO the chances of Omega replacing this dial under warranty, without first seeing the whole watch, is low...
That's what my contact at the AD told me they did. He is a very high level executive at the biggest AD in the UAE. I don't know how, but i'm glad he got it sorted for me. One of the reasons I considered getting it done in Dubai rather than the US.
 
Posts
27,915
Likes
71,095
That's what my contact at the AD told me they did. He is a very high level executive at the biggest AD in the UAE. I don't know how, but i'm glad he got it sorted for me. One of the reasons I considered getting it done in Dubai rather than the US.

I'm inclined to believe this would be more of a courtesy repair, than a warranty repair. Same result for you, but a different decision making process for Omega.
 
Posts
7,051
Likes
13,157
That's what my contact at the AD told me they did. He is a very high level executive at the biggest AD in the UAE. I don't know how, but i'm glad he got it sorted for me. One of the reasons I considered getting it done in Dubai rather than the US.
Glad it's fixed but it sounds like you had inside help in Dubai (personal connection), otherwise it wouldn't have mattered whether you had it done in the UAE, USA or Timbukto. It's quite possible the AD paid for the new dial and comped it to you as a friend. It worked out for you but I don't think the service you got is indicative of Omega sevice anyone else should expect in a similar situation.