What should I Do?

I don’t think you are quite looking at what @Sherbie is pointing it out. There is a deformation in the channel one pusher is sitting in compared to the other. I highlighted it differently. If you look at the red line on the top pusher, you will see more material. As you follow the pusher channel up towards the blue arrow, a very distinct notch leading to less material shown by the blue arrow. Comparing this pusher channel to the other pusher channel (shown by the red line/arrow) where the edge is defined and completely straight. You case does appear to have damage.

heres a better pic it was the angle which i took it