Universal Geneve Watches On Ebay

Posts
5,610
Likes
8,726
Not sure about the service history of this watch 😁 (and I think it is a redial)
 
Posts
69
Likes
150
I just don't think it came out of the factory with that dial on it. Is it an Alpina dial?
It came out with that dial. Known in the archives as well. 32903. I have documented 3 of them
 
Posts
876
Likes
2,171
Whilst I'd agree that white gold doesn't feature widely in the UG back catalogue I'm also not aware that this is something perceived as particularly valuable to collectors. Can't blame them for trying but can't see it making much difference - still can't see a 32mm precious metal calibre 42 selling with much of a significant uplift on the scrap metal value.
 
Posts
10
Likes
16
Whilst I'd agree that white gold doesn't feature widely in the UG back catalogue I'm also not aware that this is something perceived as particularly valuable to collectors. Can't blame them for trying but can't see it making much difference - still can't see a 32mm precious metal calibre 42 selling with much of a significant uplift on the scrap metal value.

Thanks for the input. I know an 18k yellow gold cal 42 can be had for well under 1k but they used the term “unicorn” as in something close to piece unique or extremely rare. I wanted to check here to see if that’s just marketing being marketing.
 
Posts
876
Likes
2,171
I don't think they are lying when they say they are rare - I just don't think there's anybody out there ready to pay a massive premium.
 
Posts
169
Likes
383
I just reread that epic thread on UG/Zenith/Martel from watchuseek discussing all this. It's very complicated, and somewhat hard to follow. There's a lot of very good info in that thread but it's not clear to me that any definite conclusions were reached, but there were lots of opinions. Whatever the relationship between UG and Martel, it seems very closely related, not clear if they were exclusive suppliers, or essentially a partially owned subsidiary, or a completely independent company. Plus the fact that the movement manufacture building has a giant sign on the outside that say Universal, but some people suggest that is just a promotional mockup, not a historical photograph, but I did not see this proven. Plus the cross over of the same staff in high level positions between the companies. The fact that UG owns some of the patents on what some people were considering Martel inventions, so perhaps they were purchased from Martel by UG (not only the movements but the patents). It all gets into a level of complexity that requires very precise definitions of language used to describe these relationships, rather than very general terms like who "made" something, or if these are "separate" companies, etc.

It seems to me that UG had a unique relationship with Martel, not shared by any other company. It's not clear to me the precise nature of that relationship, if they simply had an exclusive contract, and/or if UG owned a partial, dominant, or complete percentage of Martel. It seems to me Zenith did not share this same relationship with Martel early on, otherwise they would not have gone "through" UG to source Martel movements, nor would there by the kind of documentation of Zenith models in the UG archives, suggesting not only movements but complete watches were provided to Zenith by UG during this time period.

Later on it appears Zenith purchased/gained control/ownership of Martel, so these relationships were not fixed and changed over time, from the 30s to the 60s, so it's important to talk about specific models and specific time periods, not generalized over decades.

Anyhow, interesting stuff. Would be curious what conclusions other people have reached from that thread. @LouS was a major contributor from OF, wish we still had him as a regular poster around here.

I think that's a pretty good summary. The WUS thread is one of my favorites on the web. It's satisfying to see collector communities come together to research historical details out of sheer interest for the hobby. @LouS's objective contributions are part of what make it so good, especially as by his own description he "lost the debate". His own summary of it can be read here: https://omegaforums.net/threads/phi...rave-new-world-again.30456/page-2#post-345980

I wonder if we ought to make a new (meta-) thread with some commentary on the relationship between UG, Martel, and Zenith. You're right that much is open to interpretation, but I think some baseline facts can be established based on the WUS thread and other information.
 
Posts
3,264
Likes
7,748
I think that's a pretty good summary. The WUS thread is one of my favorites on the web. It's satisfying to see collector communities come together to research historical details out of sheer interest for the hobby. @LouS's objective contributions are part of what make it so good, especially as by his own description he "lost the debate". His own summary of it can be read here: https://omegaforums.net/threads/phi...rave-new-world-again.30456/page-2#post-345980

I wonder if we ought to make a new (meta-) thread with some commentary on the relationship between UG, Martel, and Zenith. You're right that much is open to interpretation, but I think some baseline facts can be established based on the WUS thread and other information.

it is an extraordinary thread, amazing research, epitomizes what forum/hobbyist based research can accomplish. As you say, because it's unfolding in "thread" format, it's chaotic, a summary would be nice. I wonder if the primary stakeholders in that thread would agree on what the outcome was? I'm still not sure everyone was completely on the same page by the end.