Thoughts on two 166.024s?

Hey all

I've been looking for a nice sm300 diver to replace a dearly departed recent piece and ran into this nice example :

http://www.ebay.com/itm/RARE-1968-O...iangle-Watch-100-Stock-SERVICED-/261944436751

My thoughts:

1) Open 6 and 9 fonts look correct
2) No stubby minute markers
3) White border around date box
4) Sword hand correct for 1968
5) Bezel looks correct
6) Pretty big scratch on the case back, and some smaller scratches elsewhere. Has correct caseback font with flat top A

My big concerns:

1) how new the dial looks and the uneven aging of the lume. The description says:

"Factory authentic matte black dial with large luminous triangular 12 o'clock marker, luminous hour markers at other positions (with adjacent Arabic numerals at 6 and 9 positions), date only window at 3 o'clock, luminous sword hour and pencil minute hands, and arrowhead sweep second hand with luminous tip. This dial is original and is marked (from top down) with Omega logo, "Omega," "Automatic," Seamaster 300," and "T Swiss Made T" (below 6 o'clock marker)"

Factory authentic? Fishy huh?

2) What's going on with the movement and inside caseback (have asked for pictures)


In the alternative there is this guy, which seems more honest:

http://m.ebay.com/itm/60s-Omega-Seamaster-300-Date-Big-Triangle-Dial-Automatic-Divers-Watch-ST166024-/271935655818

1) Dial Looks correct as does bezel
2)looks like some serious corrosion/pitting on the case (as seen in the movement pic)
3) the dial and hands look so new, that it seems suspicious, even though the description claims they are original.



What do you guys think? The waters of the 'Bay are treacherous, so wanted some experienced guides before I waded in.


Thanks so much in advance, guys!

Edited to add: I plan on offering a fair bit less then the BiN price.

Thanks @flame @emilio @ping pong patina . I'll petition the mods for an exception on the WTB forum 😗

Welp, dang it if I didn't find another example I have a question about. Here is a 165.014, sans big triangle obviously. Bezel seems to be in good shape (is it original?), dial lume has gone a bit brown, but not terrible and we've lost the lume in the second hand, hour and minute hands look ok. The engraving on the back is weak. Crown looks like a replacement. Bracelet, but replacement endlinks.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-OME...AUTO-STAINLESS-STEEL-MENS-WATCH-/281770586125

What do you guys think?