Yes I actually did end up pulling the trigger. I'm not yet a hardcore collector (still a med student) so the reliability and included service were important to me. I didn't mind the case polishing too much because I feel like most of the angles and design are preserved (will take a couple years of wear for the "brand new" shine to wear off, though!), and I decided that the hands could be replaced with correct ones down the road and it wasn't a huge issue. I actually love the patina on the dial, which was my biggest reason for pulling the trigger. In person, especially, it has a deep champagne/sunburst hue, and in some lights it even gives off a hint of a salmon. While I know that this is not the "totally original, untouched" connoisseurs piece, I am happy with the purchase, and this watch will definitely get lots of wear! I really appreciate all the input from the community!