Blunt, but accurate. My concern, TBH, is that the OP might be overestimating the sentimental value for his father. Most people really don't want to preserve the condition of such a badly damaged watch. Yes, some charming patina is worth preserving, but there are limits.
On the other hand, maybe the watch has a lot of sentimental value for the OP himself, which he can certainly evaluate.
Please see my bump above, of my post from page 1 yesterday... think some may have missed it when we went to page 2 - my fault for writing all of those quick replies after my much longer post!
In any case, yeah I think at this point I'm putting greater sentimental value on this watch than my dad is. He knows I am looking to get it fixed - I asked him for it, I didn't sneak over to their house and sneak it out of the drawer.
😀 But to him it would be more like, cool it works again! I honestly think he puts more value on that original gold band that he had melted down when it wore out, and re-forged into a new, non-standard but definitely still gold band, which he now wears with my crappy old gold-plated Seiko LOL.
I view this watch more as an heirloom - the watch my grandfather gave to my dad when my parents got married, which will someday get passed down to my son.
As I said on that post I bumped above, [ want to know if I can get just the movement replaced, and the crown obviously - just enough that it works again, with a proper automatic movement. I know the case and the dial have all kinds of cosmetic wear, and to me that just makes it more special. Again, as long as those don't affect the functionality of the watch.
Based on what you all have said, I agree that taking it to Omega is a bad idea - certainly would be the most expensive, and take the longest, and they I'm sure will insist on fully restoring it cosmetically as well as mechanically - more $$$$ for them!
What I want to do right now is find that "good, independent watchmaker" that several of you have suggested, take it to them, have them open up that monocoque case and see just how badly the last guy messed it up when he put the quartz movement in it. And then tell me exactly which parts we'll need to get to restore the movement, but keep it cosmetically the same, other than whatever changes are required to get it to work mechanically - that's it.
So back to my last question... when I Google watchmakers, I get either expensive watch dealers/jewelers, or the little shops in malls that replace watch batteries! Can't seem to find anything in between. Trying to find someone that looks like I can go to them with my request above, and they will (a) be able to handle it, and (b) not try to totally fleece me. I do like the idea of just telling them it was a garage sale find, or maybe that a relative found it in a drawer, but not make a big deal out of it - I just want to see if I can make it functional again.
Having said that, are any of you familiar with the Philadelphia, PA suburbs, enough to recommend a good independent watchmaker around here?
And also, does this look like a decent place to start?
https://sansomwatches.com/
https://www.yelp.com/biz/sansom-watches-wayne
Thanks again in advance, and I really do appreciate everyone's feedback - it was a lot more than I expected! This seems to be a very cool and active group.