Stuck springbar tip...still stuck...

Posts
7,111
Likes
23,095
I suggest soaking in alcohol or acetone or vinegar. Start with the vinegar and leave it overnight.

A machinist mentioned this too, but said to be careful because the vinegar can corrode the metal if left submerged too long. No personal experience with it obviously.
 
Posts
7,580
Likes
13,991
A machinist mentioned this too, but said to be careful because the vinegar can corrode the metal if left submerged too long. No personal experience with it obviously.
Or, you could revert to the obvious answer previously discussed....just use a new springbar.
 
Posts
16,856
Likes
47,862
Omron make a good little tool for solving this problem, can put you in touch with a salesman.
Save you a heap of time (and we know time is money) on your diagnostics 👍

 
Posts
17,634
Likes
36,877
WD40- that’s my new answer for everything. The duct tape of solvents 🙄

Also the solvent of duct tapes.

😁
 
Posts
711
Likes
748
A spring bar is supposed to, well, spring. If it doesn’t, your watch falls to the sidewalk. Hopefully you catch it.

This has been a really entertaining thread. But in all seriousness, @M'Bob I laud the effort to try to keep things as original as possible. I don't agree, but my opinion doesn't matter. You've already been given better ideas/advice than I can offer.

I used to keep track and make sure to use original springbars, until I started noticing how faulty they could be. @Larry S 's comment underscores a scary reality that many people don't really consider. A few months ago I bought a 60's cosmic in excellent original condition, with what looked like its ancient original spring bars. One of them literally broke in 3 pieces immediately after arriving and going on my wrist. You never know when bad luck strikes. A week and a half ago, my father was at the pharmacy and wearing his Bond style Seamaster (which he bought new in 2000 while working for an AD). While walking around, one of the springbars snapped and the watch fell off his wrist. The worst part was that didn't notice and he would have lost the watch if it wasn't for a kind woman noticing and running after him. I've bought two watches in the last few months at a discount because the same thing happened to other unlucky chaps. Both were missing one of their original end-links, and one of them also had a broken balance staff.

I now change out the springbars on EVERY vintage that I buy. I recommend the same to everybody. If the original spring bars matter to you, I would keep them somewhere in a box. I personally throw them out rather than risk them being reused. The only springbars that I think would matter keeping are rare original gold spring-bars. But again, this is just my two cents.
 
Posts
7,111
Likes
23,095
I now change out the springbars on EVERY vintage that I buy. I recommend the same to everybody. If the original spring bars matter to you, I would keep them somewhere in a box. I personally throw them out rather than risk them being reused. The only springbars that I think would matter keeping are rare original gold spring-bars. But again, this is just my two cents.

I appreciate your insights, and totally agree when it comes to the bars that hold the strap or bracelet to the watch.

This is a bracelet clasp bar, and the difference is that the original ones, at least for the flat-links, had very little travel with the tips, which you can see in the photo on the right. The other bar, which fits fine and is aftermarket, needs a much greater compression to get under the clasp. That’s the one on the left.

Why does this matter to me? If you’ve ever replaced or moved the position of the after market bar, because of the greater spring tension, it can easily launch right into your eye. This does not happen with the original. Whether it was designed the way purposely, I can’t say. But I know it’s difficult to tell which one is in the clasp until you depress the tip and release it.

I’m in health care, and I deal with physical disabilities all day long. In the future, I don’t want some unsuspecting, neophyte hobbyist getting a penetrating eye injury.

 
Posts
29,246
Likes
75,644
I suggest soaking in alcohol or acetone or vinegar. Start with the vinegar and leave it overnight.

Vinegar is an acid...IMO not a good idea if the intent is to use the bar...
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,800
Vinegar is an acid...IMO not a good idea if the intent is to use the bar...
You would want to neutralize it, certainly. One would hope stainless steel would stand up to vinegar.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,800
A bracelet spring bar is special, as you can clearly see. Using the spring bar for the watch lugs is the wrong kind.
 
Posts
31
Likes
13
I've had great results attaching a tube to the unstuck end and spraying ether into the barrel of the spring bar. This does not usually loosen the stuck end but when I introduce a flame...

More constructively, have you tried compressed air?
 
Posts
795
Likes
1,157
As a last resort, I would try boiling the thing in water!
 
Posts
316
Likes
287
I had a similar challenge with corrosion on a pair of bracelet spring bars that would not compress. After multiple tries I finally got one side of one of them to work, but badly. I tried vinegar, acetone, WD 40 and heat. No luck, they might as well have been welded solid. There was a brown goo on them, but the problem went deeper than that.

Ultimately, I had to get them cut (jeweller saw) to get the bracelet off.

I wish you good luck, but based on that experience I am not optimistic.
 
Posts
23,502
Likes
52,241
If dirt and debris is inside the cylinder, it is not always going to be possible to remove it. But more importantly, it's not necessarily simply a matter of cleaning out dirt and debris. Spring-bars are made of relatively cheap disposable materials, and the springs themselves can become fatigued, corroded and weak, and ultimately they can fail. If the spring is not strong and resilient (and this inevitably occurs with time and exposure to ambient conditions), no amount of cleaning will repair the part.
 
Posts
7,111
Likes
23,095
If dirt and debris is inside the cylinder, it is not always going to be possible to remove it. But more importantly, it's not necessarily simply a matter of cleaning out dirt and debris. Spring-bars are made of relatively cheap disposable materials, and the springs themselves can become fatigued, corroded and weak, and ultimately they can fail. If the spring is not strong and resilient (and this inevitably occurs with time and exposure to ambient conditions), no amount of cleaning will repair the part.

I don’t really understand what you’re saying here.

If one doesn’t attemp to remove the debris, using a variety of materials or methods, how would one know if the debris can be removed?

Are you implying that, if an end of a spring bar is stuck, it’s a reliable indicator that the spring’s useful life has expired? How does one know, or test, that a spring is still, “strong and resilient”? Is there a generally accepted expiration date?
 
Posts
31
Likes
13
I don’t really understand what you’re saying here.

If one doesn’t attemp to remove the debris, using a variety of materials or methods, how would one know if the debris can be removed?

Are you implying that, if an end of a spring bar is stuck, it’s a reliable indicator that the spring’s useful life has expired? How does one know, or test, that a spring is still, “strong and resilient”? Is there a generally accepted expiration date?

I'm new here, and my introduction to you has been through this thread. Take it for what its worth but if you are working on an Omega and intent on saving something unserviceable that is:
1. readily available,
2. worth $0.009,
3. critical to keeping the watch safely and securely on your wrist,
then your crusade for originality is at some level, admirable, but more realistically, misplaced and unjustified. In all the threads I have seen over the last two months I've been here, not one has mentioned whether or not the springbars were authentic or original. There have been a lot of good suggestions here, so why not spend your time utilizing them rather than poking holes in them?
 
Posts
29,246
Likes
75,644
Are you implying that, if an end of a spring bar is stuck, it’s a reliable indicator that the spring’s useful life has expired?

YES!

Is there a generally accepted expiration date?

At every service, so approx. every 5 years.
 
Posts
29,246
Likes
75,644
You would want to neutralize it, certainly. One would hope stainless steel would stand up to vinegar.

The spring inside isn't stainless...
 
Posts
7,111
Likes
23,095
There have been a lot of good suggestions here, so why not spend your time utilizing them rather than poking holes in them?

Do you not believe, as Plato did, that the struggle between opposing points of view brings about a new or greater understanding of the issues?