Seamaster Deville - Bent Lugs

Posts
8
Likes
1
Hello. I am sending this watch out for servicing. I just noticed that the outside lugs are bent in about 1mm so the band was crammed in there pretty tight. It is the gold filled case. I was tempted to try to unbend but, as i figured the watch repair people said no go, it will snap them. I am thinking that my only option is to search for a case but that might be tough to find. It should be a 550 movement. I will confirm that, (and the case number) when the watchmaker opens it up. Any suggestions? Thank you
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,937
That’s a pretty bad bend. If it were solid gold then it could be easier as it’s a softer metal (less brittle). The technique my watchmaker used is what a jeweler would do (on a solid gold UG case). Strip, heat lug and carefully bend back- then clean and polish.
The fear is not just snapping it off, but deforming the case trying to bend it back. If you have nothing to lose- then go for it.
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
That’s a pretty bad bend. If it were solid gold then it could be easier as it’s a softer metal (less brittle). The technique my watchmaker used is what a jeweler would do (on a solid gold UG case). Strip, heat lug and carefully bend back- then clean and polish.
The fear is not just snapping it off, but deforming the case trying to bend it back. If you have nothing to lose- then go for it.
Yeah, if i had a backup case i would just go for it. It was my grandfather's watch so . . .
I think my best option is servicing now, than do a case swap if and when i can find one.
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,937
Case swap is the safest route. When you get it serviced, they can give you the case reference number that’s printed inside the back- then you can hunt for an identical one.
If you don’t mind spending a little more money as this is a family heirloom, you could ask a local jeweler if they could do it. They would need to do it the same way I mentioned above- strip and heat with a torch, then bend back and refinish/replate the case as it will leave braising discoloration on the gold plate. It can be done- but a donor case will be cheaper.
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
Thanks.
My other issue is that it looks like the crown stem is a bit too tall. See how far it is from the case?
Maybe i kill 2 birds with one stone finding that donor.
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,795
the situation you have is similar to many people trying to preserve their family heirloom vintage rolex. replacing a major component like the case is basically changing watches, not preserving grandpa's watch. your lugs look typical of what happened to vintage watches years go...someone adapted the lugs to fit a strap.
once you get the movement removed, rest the inner half of the lug against a sharp wooden edge and gently tap the outer part of the lug with a small wooden or plastic hammer to bring the lug back into position. gentle is the key. it's easier to control gently taps than attempting to bend the lug with wrapped pliers, as constant pressure is too difficult to maintain and that is how lugs are snapped off.
if things go wrong then bring the case and whatever broke off to an expert goldsmith, as they can reshape and use pure 14k gold to solder things back together. I don't know where you are located, but in Manhattan's jewelry district there are jewelry repair experts that could fix that case/lugs up very reasonably so at least it's the same watch your grandpa wore. Replacing the case should be a radical last-ditch solution.
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
the situation you have is similar to many people trying to preserve their family heirloom vintage rolex. replacing a major component like the case is basically changing watches, not preserving grandpa's watch. your lugs look typical of what happened to vintage watches years go...someone adapted the lugs to fit a strap.
once you get the movement removed, rest the inner half of the lug against a sharp wooden edge and gently tap the outer part of the lug with a small wooden or plastic hammer to bring the lug back into position. gentle is the key. it's easier to control gently taps than attempting to bend the lug with wrapped pliers, as constant pressure is too difficult to maintain and that is how lugs are snapped off.
if things go wrong then bring the case and whatever broke off to an expert goldsmith, as they can reshape and use pure 14k gold to solder things back together. I don't know where you are located, but in Manhattan's jewelry district there are jewelry repair experts that could fix that case/lugs up very reasonably so at least it's the same watch your grandpa wore. Replacing the case should be a radical last-ditch solution.
Ahh, great ideas, thanks.
 
Posts
297
Likes
266
the situation you have is similar to many people trying to preserve their family heirloom vintage rolex. replacing a major component like the case is basically changing watches, not preserving grandpa's watch. your lugs look typical of what happened to vintage watches years go...someone adapted the lugs to fit a strap.
once you get the movement removed, rest the inner half of the lug against a sharp wooden edge and gently tap the outer part of the lug with a small wooden or plastic hammer to bring the lug back into position. gentle is the key. it's easier to control gently taps than attempting to bend the lug with wrapped pliers, as constant pressure is too difficult to maintain and that is how lugs are snapped off.
if things go wrong then bring the case and whatever broke off to an expert goldsmith, as they can reshape and use pure 14k gold to solder things back together. I don't know where you are located, but in Manhattan's jewelry district there are jewelry repair experts that could fix that case/lugs up very reasonably so at least it's the same watch your grandpa wore. Replacing the case should be a radical last-ditch solution.
This!!! If you replace the case, it's not grandpa's watch anymore. If in 20 years your son or grandson replaces the movement, then it's really not grandpa's watch anymore!!!
 
Posts
825
Likes
6,615
This!!! If you replace the case, it's not grandpa's watch anymore. If in 20 years your son or grandson replaces the movement, then it's really not grandpa's watch anymore!!!

It will be Seamaster DeVille of Theseus.
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
Plus, if i did find a case, then i could try fixing the original without worrying so much.
 
Posts
297
Likes
266
Plus, if i did find a case, then i could try fixing the original without worrying so much.
Yes, that's a thought. Plus you could wear the watch while the original case is out being repaired (that could take months). When the repaired case returns, you could sell the replacement.
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
That is my best plan. It might take some time to find a replacement. Mine has a flat back but maybe once i get the numbers i can also determine the seamonster case equivalent. That way my options double.
 
Posts
3,232
Likes
12,694
My other issue is that it looks like the crown stem is a bit too tall. See how far it is from the case?

That, at least, isn't a real issue. The stems come in a standard length that's usually way too long for those 34mm cases, as the movements were also used in larger watches. Your WM will clip a bit off/use sanding paper for the fine tuning, it's no big deal. 😀
 
Posts
8
Likes
1
Oh thats great news. I will also be looking for a new crown as, mine is very worn.

Thank you for that info.
 
Posts
375
Likes
2,886
I had the same problem with a gold capped seamaster deville I bought a year or so ago. Covered the bent lug with a thick microfiber cloth, got a plier and straightened it by gripping the end of the lug. This was mid-air. It was definitely ballsy lol wouldn't recommend it... wouldn't do it again 😕 But it's not really that hard