Call me paranoid, but before I purchase any watch from my AD, I always ask them to run a test on the watch and hand me the print out of the beats, rate, accuracy, etc...
It may not detect what the real issue is with a watch, but if anything is off at least they can look into it before you walk away with the watch or request a new one. One thing I don't do is purchase the display models unless it is the last piece and waiting list is high, but even then ask the watch be tested anyway 馃榾.
Again sorry to hear that about your speedy, rattle seems really off, my guess is the watch took a big jolt but if no sign of dents on the case, it could be either opened previously or quality escape from omega (highly unlikely).