I suspect that the original dial was fine in this case, and obviously they didn't even polish the case or the bracelet. Maybe they replaced the crown and crystal.
Correct. New crown and crystal. Dial was fine. They had to rebuild the movement. Didn't touch the case or bracelet. Price was $550 total.
It looks great - the only quibble I have is the replaced crown. If the plating hasn't gone from the original, the rubber seal in the original one could be changed by a good watchmaker.
I was always of them assumption that the seal is captured under a pressed in retainer and cannot be changed. Have you had luck with this and if so, could you share the process?