Most Underrated Vintage Rolex

Posts
707
Likes
1,041
In your opinion, which is the most underrated, undervalued vintage Rolex. For me it's the Air King, but the Datejust isn't far behind.
 
Posts
25,980
Likes
27,647
Zephyr.

Only made for a few years from the late 50's into the 60's, same Oyster case as the DJ, same Rolex calibers, excellent cross hair dials, yet nobody has gone gaga over them.
 
Posts
1,560
Likes
8,023
In my view it would be the vintage gold sport watches. I don't know the numbers, but there are far fewer (maybe by a magnitude of 100:1?) vintage gold nipple dial Subs out there than 5512s, 5513s, or steel 1680s, yet the prices of many of the latter are not that far off from the gold 1680s. It may be a reflection of who likes what but you could probably use that explanation in relation to anything that is considered undervalued.
 
Posts
276
Likes
289
Oysterquartz in general. Such a beautiful n classic design. The bracelet arguably the best Rolex ever made prior to the 90's.


I blame it on the autoconnect.
 
Posts
8,890
Likes
28,363
Zephyr.

Only made for a few years from the late 50's into the 60's, same Oyster case as the DJ, same Rolex calibers, excellent cross hair dials, yet nobody has gone gaga over them.

The 1038 with no date... drool
 
Posts
2,678
Likes
9,836
The Daytona 6262 is the least common Daytona, produced for only one year with only 1600 made...rare by Rolex standards. Yet it sells for the same price as the far more common 6239. I would say extremely underrated and far less common than the PN Daytona.
 
Posts
9,596
Likes
27,673
Could either the OP or a moderator please change the title to "Least overrated", please?


Only slightly kidding here 😉
 
Posts
8,890
Likes
28,363
Could either the OP or a moderator please change the title to "Least overrated", please?


Only slightly kidding here 😉

"Least hyped"...
 
Posts
349
Likes
1,544
I agree that older perpetual oyster in steel, and oyster dates like 1500 are pretty good value.
 
Posts
212
Likes
566
Definitely Datejusts, even up to the five-digit acrylic models. They have a beautiful, classic vintage feel, but not crazy small at 36mm. I especially love the 1600. Very nice examples can be had for under $3K ... for now. Here's my 1977 DJ.
 
Posts
1,888
Likes
1,554
1601 & 1603 Datejusts with dials other than silver. Must be piepan!
 
Posts
212
Likes
566
1601 & 1603 Datejusts with dials other than silver. Must be piepan!

Silver is classic and very beautiful, with a great iridescence that shimmers. Also, the silver dials take on a great patina as they age.
 
Posts
3,849
Likes
27,360
I agree with Kyle. Bubblebacks are out of fashion these days because of their relatively small size, although in the 30s-40s they were considered full size for automatics (okay, Omegas were of larger diameter, but with thinner cases, as the early full-rotor design movements were necessarily thicker than bumper movements).



And a couple of my early '50s Oyster Perpetuals (34mm cases).


 
Posts
12,784
Likes
17,363
This one gets very little love from Rolex collectors:

DSCN2112.jpg~original

It's a Ref. 6634, otherwise known as a "Golden Egg". That's a fancy name for a gold-capped Oyster Perpetual. I paid a relative pittance for it and was later told by my watchmaker that the movement is worth twice as much de-cased because it may be easily dropped into a far more valuable sports model (cal. 1030).
gatorcpa
 
Posts
6
Likes
29
its the 5513 submariner for me. The 5512's have enough attention as it is, and the 5513's are sometimes viewed as a less desirable version. 5513 gilt are simply stunning!
 
Posts
2,203
Likes
2,057
5500 AKs... Must be one of the longest running models, lots of variety (something for everybody) and nearly always rather classy...