Forums Latest Members
  1. Larry S Color Commentator for the Hyperbole. Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    12,380
    Likes
    49,146
    These are outsourced components. The stuff from Minerva is at a much higher price point.
     
  2. Spruce Sunburst dial fan Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    6,527
    Likes
    50,699
    Shame no ones posted any photos. I don’t know anything about them but saw the thread and thought I’d look. No pics, so I googled images. Nothing special there then but I saw one that looked nice and expanded the image.

    The one I liked turned out to be a reasonably priced Longines Flagship Heritage :(
     
  3. redpcar Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    3,650
    Likes
    7,675
    Montblanc started making (probably just selling) watches in the late '90s. Pass.
    In my quest for watch grails, I need history.
    If they were in the "beater" price range, maybe.
    The connection with Minerva helps and are great looking. If they could only keep the Minerva name on the dial. Another pass.
     
  4. Dan S Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    18,242
    Likes
    42,094
    Second page of a thread without a single photo. What is this, a usenet discussion group? :cautious:
     
    Zapatta and Spruce like this.
  5. redpcar Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    3,650
    Likes
    7,675
    upload_2020-8-25_13-35-47.png
     
    Walrus and Dan S like this.
  6. OmegaRody Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    231
    Ok thanks for sharing your knowledge.
     
  7. OmegaRody Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    231
    Regarding the photos dont know why Im havinf trouble uploading photos from my phone so I have to rely in my desktop for that.
     
  8. kaapstadflaneur Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    371
    Likes
    3,179
    Montblanc has three levels of movements -- (1) modified ETA/Sellita, which are the least expensive (generally under US$ 5,000); (2) in-house calibres produced at Le Locle, which are mid-range (usually US$ 5,000 to US$ 10,000); and (3) Minerva-based calibres produced at Villeret (US$ 10,000+). The Minerva-based movements are very special -- and tend to be very expensive.
     
    Farmer and thelinendial like this.
  9. Marsimaxam Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    1,418
    Likes
    2,840
    I can't say I am a fan of Montblanc watches. I've read good things about their quality, price to value and innovative designs, however, I just don't see myself buying one of their watches. One of their pens... definitely.
     
  10. Spruce Sunburst dial fan Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    6,527
    Likes
    50,699
  11. OmegaRody Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    231
    can you please comment on this ones, movement level etc etc?
    download (2).jpg download (1).jpg download.jpg s-l640.jpg
     
    Walrus likes this.
  12. OmegaRody Aug 25, 2020

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    231
  13. NiceWatchMr Aug 30, 2020

    Posts
    13
    Likes
    94
    Here are my two babies...full perpetual and twinfly with mb ll 100 movement
     
    20200829_172254.jpg 20200828_235339.jpg
    OmegaRody likes this.
  14. OmegaRody Aug 30, 2020

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    231
    Love the perpetual. Got to be expensive.
     
  15. rahilb Sep 1, 2020

    Posts
    128
    Likes
    250
    I have an 1858 Automatic, the smaller size (Minerva copy); it’s a great looking watch that wears well, and the bronze two tone is quite subtle and nice.

    However the rotor noise is noticeable and the power reserve also seems quite poor; I don’t think I got a lemon as reviewers also mentioned it on release. For me the watch looks so good I just don’t really care about that... however a screw down crown would be nice.
     
    OmegaRody likes this.
  16. rahilb Sep 3, 2020

    Posts
    128
    Likes
    250
    As pics are severely lacking in this thread;

    [​IMG]
     
    Fallout Boy, Mossback and OmegaRody like this.
  17. Omegafanman Sep 4, 2020

    Posts
    4,522
    Likes
    16,859
    ref pics ..I tried on one of their perpetuals a few years back ( I think they have just launched it). It was a lot of watch for the money as I recall / good value.
     
    mb01 - Copy.jpg mb02 - Copy.jpg
  18. Grunka-lunka Oct 30, 2020

    Posts
    49
    Likes
    54
    I am fortunate to have 3 MB watches.

    I have 2 Timewalkers and a Heritage Chronometrie - all on leather straps. Whilst the movements are nice all three are Selittas and keep time very well.

    The timewalkers are lovely, but I cannot get on with the Heritage.... don’t get me wrong, it is wonderful to look at, classy and comfortable to wear.

    It’s one drawback is it sounds awful. I mean, you can hear it tick whilst wearing it, even people around me have gotten annoyed by it’s ticking. The rotor grinds so loudly that people have urged me to get it looked at!

    Which I have, by MB, under warranty.... but each time it comes back with a clean bill of health.

    I will have to part with it, sadly, I just hope that it’s new owner can forgive it more than I could.

    But yes, leather strap FTW on MBs! AA2307CC-9FD3-4214-B303-57E60641FD09.jpeg
     
    Fallout Boy likes this.
  19. wpybus Dec 11, 2020

    Posts
    3
    Likes
    4
    Sold a few watches on eBay then got these two for less than half price, I wear the silver /white dial but I’m keeping the salmon under wraps! FEAE02BD-7B13-4E62-A1D3-E799FE776ABE.jpeg 2B1E0AF5-D421-44D1-BCAC-5BAF9F8FA57E.jpeg
     
  20. kristal Dec 11, 2020

    Posts
    89
    Likes
    364
    I came across a review for a Montblanc 1858 monopusher chronograph which has a Minerva movement and is limited to 100 pieces. I think that watch is a true stunner!
    However, the price of 27k EUR seem a bit too much for a Montblanc (even for that one) since I believe even though they are trying to enter the high end watch market they are not quite there yet.
     
    Montblanc1.jpg MONTBLANC2.jpeg