@oinkitt you make a very good and powerful argument. Watches are inert objects and this one doesn’t carry the Swastika or any of the nazi symbols found on certain watches of the same era.
However, there’s a double standard.
When a watch has been worn by a single owner who happens to be a famous person or a war hero how much premium does that place on the object?
One might find it ridiculous fetishism— at least I do— as the watch is not the person. Yet people pay a lot of money when the provenance is established.
And even when the provenance is not established how many times have you heard collectors gushing over their vintage watches as if it were a person, and ooohing and aaahing, «ooh, the stories this could tell if it could speak »... or even more in the case of military watch collectors imagining the unsung heroes that wore their watches?
Well in this case.... the object also carries imagination and not everyone likes the story. If it cuts one way, it will cut the other.
Of course all wars are terrible but if there’s a clear cut case where not all things are morally equal this must be the one.
Perhaps seen from Australia it feels very far away but seen from Europe it’s very real. The wounds cut deep and are passed down generations.
For sure not everyone would have resisted or been better than anyone else, and no one’s giving lessons, however Karma’s a bitch and not evryone wants the reminder of bad memories on their wrists.
That being said, again it’s very personal.
It surely would be a much different matter if the watch were carrying Nazi symbols or had been used by what have been recognized as criminal organizations in international law- such as the SS. (In which case the sale would be illegal in a number of countries and on Ebay).
In this case the watch was issued to the regular army so it’s all fine and permissible. The only thing that started this discussion was the seller’s use of this subforum as a promotional tool to showcase his sale, plus the assertion in the sales post that’s it’s a « rare » « under the radar » item that’s a « good investment ».
Click to expand...