Love or hate this patina?

Posts

635

Likes

2,624

Kapka

·Nov 21, 2024

What do you think about this patina?
Sometimes I think it's like a piece of art and so unique. At first I was thinking that it's sucks that the patina is not even but looking again I like it more and more.

Also if someone knows how these type of patina develope please let me know. One interesting explanation that I got from one old (82) watch collector is that this happens because the owner was smoking those wooden tobacco pipes.

 

Posts

249

Likes

135

impaw

·Nov 21, 2024

I have no explanation for the uneven patina, but I am with you - I really like the watch.😍

 

Posts

3,639

Likes

8,416

bgrisso

·Nov 21, 2024

I don't mind really strong patina sometimes, but for me it needs to be somewhat even. The way this is distributed across the dial doesn't really do a lot for me, if it was more homogeneous, would like it better

 

Posts

137

Likes

147

pitbos

·Nov 21, 2024

When I first started getting interested in tropical/patina watches, I always gravitated towards the watches that had the heaviest evidence of change. With Speedmasters, I used to love the very heavy brown dials with lots of gradiation and shades of brown. Over time, as I've gone deeper and deeper into exploring these dials, I tend to like the subtle and homogeneous patinantion the best. A nice, subtle even chocolate brown is my favourite patinanted Speedmaster dial by far and holds my interest indefintely.

For this particular watch, while it does look nice, I feel like I would loose interest in it over time as it's simply "too much". Beauty in the eye of the beholder I guess.

 

Posts

8,962

Likes

74,640

Spruce

·Nov 21, 2024·Sunburst dial fan

👎🏼

 

Posts

897

Likes

2,849

Porteroso

·Nov 21, 2024

I think it is lucky that the indeces are gold. Silver/chrome, or any sort of mixed material, and it would be too much.

Seems like this could be pretty cool in person, on the wrist. On the internet, it is just a worn watch, nearly catastrophically damaged. Dime a dozen, and not impressive.

 

Posts

24,723

Likes

54,916

Dan S

·Nov 21, 2024

Too uneven for me personally but it’s all personal taste.

 

Posts

13,365

Likes

23,203

Davidt

·Nov 21, 2024

Too much for me. Some patina if its evenly spread and relatively uniform can be really nice but this is too much imo

 

Posts

894

Likes

3,755

rendo

·Nov 21, 2024·faux legend

Too much for me, too. It looks like the right side got some extra tanning oil through the case tube.

 

Posts

1,345

Likes

5,923

rbob99

·Nov 21, 2024

Too much for me, also.

 

Posts

6,893

Likes

55,043

noelekal

·Nov 21, 2024·Home For Wayward Watches

Uneven and too much of a “good thing.”

 

Posts

448

Likes

218

Wat-1

·Nov 21, 2024

Yea it’s a little uneven for me . get the heat gun out and give the other side a blast.

 

Posts

7,732

Likes

14,314

Evitzee

·Nov 21, 2024

Patina, no. That's just damage.

 

Posts

3,598

Likes

7,672

mac_omega

·Nov 21, 2024

I don´t want to comment on the look of the patina because this is a very subjective choice.

But I want to try to explain how this patina evolved. It has nothing to do with smoking.
We know that old lacquers of that period did not stand time well.
They become porous or develop fine cracks and hydrogen sulphide gas (which is always present in the air in small traces) can penetrate to the silver of the dial over time. The silver reacts with the hydrogen sulphide to form silver sulphide. This can result in colours ranging from pink to various shades of brown to almost black.

Edited: Nov 21, 2024

 

Posts

1,831

Likes

9,329

bubba48

·Nov 21, 2024

👎

 

Posts

13,805

Likes

53,817

Larry S

·Nov 21, 2024·Color Commentator for the Hyperbole.

I was gonna do thumbs down. But there is something mesmerizing about that dial. Kinda like Hubble pics only shades of brown. So👍

 

Posts

635

Likes

2,624

Kapka

·Nov 21, 2024

mac_omega

I don´t want to comment on the look of the patina because this is a very personal choice.

But I want to try to explain how this patina evolved. It has nothing to do with smoking.
We know that old lacquers of that period did not stand time well.
They become porous or develop fine cracks and hydrogen sulphide gas (which is always present in the air in small traces) can penetrate to the silver of the dial over time. The silver reacts with the hydrogen sulphide to form silver sulphide. This can result in colours ranging from pink to various shades of brown to almost black.

That sounds like a far more scientific and reasonable answer then what my old mate had 😁 Thanks a lot. Do we know when these lacqueres got significantly improved?
60s?

 

Posts

8,201

Likes

28,912

Tony C.

·Nov 21, 2024·Ωf Jury member

mac_omega

But I want to try to explain how this patina evolved. It has nothing to do with smoking.
We know that old lacquers of that period did not stand time well.
They become porous or develop fine cracks and hydrogen sulphide gas (which is always present in the air in small traces) can penetrate to the silver of the dial over time. The silver reacts with the hydrogen sulphide to form silver sulphide. This can result in colours ranging from pink to various shades of brown to almost black.

Thank you, Erich. Can you explain why the lacquers used by Omega seem to have been more vulnerable to such chemical interactions than those of other large manufacturers?

 

Posts

605

Likes

1,915

hant26

·Nov 21, 2024

uneven, yes. Beautiful, sure. After a proper service, I think it will be perfect on the wrist. The 36mm case is fit for modern standard too.

 

Posts

3,598

Likes

7,672

mac_omega

·Nov 21, 2024

Tony C.

Thank you, Erich. Can you explain why the lacquers used by Omega seem to have been more vulnerable to such chemical interactions than those of other large manufacturers?

TBH I don´t know but I have an assumption: As Omega did not produce dials themselves and they were bought from dial manufacturers it may depend on the contractor. Patek Philippe and Rolex bought dials from Stern Frères company, Omega mostly from Lemrich & Co. and later from Flückiger & Cie. (former Zélim Jacot "ZJ"). Most probably these companies used lacquers of different quality or even different chemical composition/origin?
Just a thought...