Without pictures, it is hard to say for certain if this bezel was severely misaligned or not — some people have a very low tolerance for ANY misalignment on a $5000 watch, and they often don’t account for parallax when looking at the watch.
With that said, I have never owned a diver where the bezel marks line up perfectly all around the dial. I own 3 divers at the moment (a Seamaster, a quartz Certina, and a Formex Reef). All have some level of misalignment at some point. For example, on the Seamaster, when the bezel marks are lined up perfectly with the 15 minute and 45 minute markers on the dial, the bezel lume plot is aligned, but the 25-minute bezel mark is just slightly rotated CCW from the corresponding mark on the dial, and the 30-minute bezel counter is also slightly off center.
On the Certina, 20, 25, 30, and 35-minute markers are rotated about 1-click CCW from the dial marker.
I can show you pictures of Rolex Subs that have a similar issue, primarily at the 25-, 30-, and 35- minute markers.
You have to remember that the dial is a different diameter than the bezel and with small, reasonable tolerances for manufacture, there are likely to be some slight deviations somewhere on the bezel. By slight, I’m talking a 1 click offset. I believe in the QC-stage, they only focus on the bezel lume plot matching the 12 o’clock marker on the dial.
Click to expand...