Does anyone have any experience with ceramic watches such as the dark side of the moon? I have heard rumblings that they are brittle and prone to cracking if dropped or banged. Is this really true?
I can only speak from personal experience, but I wear a ceramic as a daily and it remains in one piece despite having been knocked on doors etc. There are a few horror stories out there of people shattering ceramic watches, but the number of horror stories compared to the quantity of ceramic watches out in the wild is a really low ratio. If the issue was that bad no one would be buying them, and manufacturers would have stopped making them.
Here are a couple links for you to read through. Ceramic is durable but brittle when it comes to impact. https://omegaforums.net/threads/omega-speedmaster-gsotm-chipped-lug.36135/ https://omegaforums.net/threads/i-want-a-dsotm-but-scared-of-ceramic-comments-please.43429/ https://omegaforums.net/threads/can-someone-explain-omegas-ceramic-watch-cases.25204/ https://omegaforums.net/threads/bad-day-on-the-dark-side-of-the-moon.19011/ https://omegaforums.net/threads/gsotm-chipped.38886/ https://omegaforums.net/threads/new-dsotm-small-issue.117171/
Based on the number of times I have smacked my DSOTM hard against door handles, walls, a metal railing once, it's not enough of a concern to fret about. Once or twice the surface I hit got damaged, but never the watch.
Yes, they can chip or break, and if they do the cost to repair is very high. If you plan to get one, insurance is a must.
Ceramic is great at compression over a wide area. Ceramic is not great at torque or pin point blows. I’d never own a ceramic watch.
I dropped darkside on wife’ granite counter top, while changing strap. A piece of the white countertop chipped off. Wife is pissed. if you must own a ceramic watch, don’t get marry. Just saying...
DSOTM is my go to watch now for international travel and London (since 2015).... Risk of a scratch (almost zero)…. risk of being mugged / robbed for it …… almost zero... Risk of it smashing...based on my drunken altercation with a lamppost in Berlin - fairly low. I am happy with those odds compared to everything else in my collection.... and it can run duel time on the sub dial :0) .
I've had my GSOTM for two years now and it still looks brand new. The worst I've done to it is probably take out a chunk of plaster wall at the office though. No drops or falls so far. Added a ceramic PO to my collection this year too, had 0 hesitation over the ceramic case. I also have both insured through a separate "Personal Articles Policy" though. Full reimbursement for damage (repairs), loss and theft.
Ceramic has a unique look, feel and fit when worn. If this appeals to you then get one. It's a good idea to insure any watch that costs several thousand (or more) regardless of what material it's made of. I insure mine for theft and accidental damage, just as I would any of my watches not covered by a standard home insurance policy. I wear it daily and enjoy it without worrying about chips or damage (or did before it stopped, not related to any bumps or knocks).
I’d love to own one DSOTM as well! But I won’t not because of the ceramic case but it’s size and thickness. Why can’t Omega just make a smaller and thinner piece? It’d have been a real contender to the Rolex Daytona.
Have you tried one on in person? The thickness really isnt noticeable to me. I'd say it probably fits well on a wrist as small as 6.5.
There is a Planet Ocean 600M in 39.5mm ceramic that I'm currently contemplating. I can't get over the price right now, but size-wise, it fits the bill for me.
Anybody knows how much lighter (in %?) is the ceramic version of a given model comparing to it's steel counterpart?
Kinda hard to make that comparison cause there arent exact counterparts from what I can think of. Easiest to just pick two models you wanna compare and check the specs.
Planet Ocean 600M in 39.5mm is exactly an example of a model in steel and ceramic. Unfortunately, omega web page does not mention head weight, not even in PDF datasheet...
Ah whoops, forgot those smaller POs. I only own a 45.5mm PO in ceramic, so I cant help there. Best to just go to a shop and hope they have both for you to try on.