They'll think we were stark raving mad.
I really like this watch: for me the dial spotting is novel in that there is presumably a process to make it, almost like textured metal dials. I don't think of it as trying to be fake patina but instead think a new way of finishing dials that is aesthetic for the same reasons as the old models that have similar spotting. I can't find anything on the Longines site though, if anyone figured out how to order one please let me know!
Agreed, for me the Longines dial treatment is creative and just as valid as "fauxtina" on hour markers and the brownish tones used on some vintage reissues to emulate tropical dials. The Railmaster 60th LE was a gorgeous reissue and I am sure that it looks nicer with the warm "fauxtina" tones than the original dial released in 57.
If vintage watch patina looked horrible (sickly yellow / green for example), the vintage watch market would not have taken off. All Longines and others are doing is emulating the aesthetic beauty of aged watches😀
The difference is that spotting is seen as an effect of poor storage.
To most collectors, spotting is often considered "damage" while lume patina is considered an inevitable part of the life cycle of a vintage watch.
The spotting on dial is perhaps due to decay in the period paint rather “damage” as almost all images on the internet have similar dial spots.
"Damage" is subjective to collectors. Aged lume is almost never considered damage. Yet spotting is. Regardless of why.
It's just the current perception these days.
It looks great. I'm shocked by the spotty dial, But I think one just has to accept a watch as it is. If it looks good, wear it.
I'm more on the fence about a crown that style & diameter on an auto, & not putting "automatic" on the dial.
The beauty of the watch is the minimalist dial without date and only Longines written on it as in the original watch. I would have preferred a manual winding and drilled lugs to make it perfect. But perfection is quite elusive indeed.