Community Stories

Zenith bumper on Catawiki

Geezer
Posts
453
Likes
1,303
Nice watch.

Why do you think the case has been replaced?

I don't see anything wrong with the watch except for the replacement crown.
 
DirtyDozen12
Posts
2,820
Likes
4,924
Below are photos of the watch for posterity. I am not well-versed in Zenith, but the font of the outer scale strikes me as odd. Also, is the signature too large? I posted two examples that look comparable further below. The font of the outer scales looks familiar, to me, from dials that were used by other brands from the period.

upload_2023-11-6_21-48-9.png upload_2023-11-6_21-47-41.png upload_2023-11-6_21-57-24.png upload_2023-11-6_21-57-54.png


Source: https://www.alexandrelandre.com/en/...8k-yellow-gold-bracelet-case-round-case-press
upload_2023-11-6_22-16-34.png upload_2023-11-6_22-19-6.png upload_2023-11-6_22-20-52.png upload_2023-11-6_22-21-35.png


Source: https://www.vintagegoldwatches.com/product/zenith-automatic-cal-133-8-9ct-c1954/
upload_2023-11-6_22-22-49.png upload_2023-11-6_22-23-42.png
 
Geezer
Posts
453
Likes
1,303
I think you're right, the dial does look a bit off. The signature is very big, and I would also expect it to be printed with "automatic".
 
CaptainWinsor
Posts
1,986
Likes
3,558
Geezer Geezer
Nice watch.

Why do you think the case has been replaced?

I don't see anything wrong with the watch except for the replacement crown.

I have an extensive list of the bumpers with serial numbers and case movements. In my records, this was previously in an 18K case
 
CaptainWinsor
Posts
1,986
Likes
3,558
Yes the dial looks off too. Didn’t notice the no AUTOMATIC. Also, the dial style looks more like the early 133s and 133.8 but the serial is very late in the production run
 
Tony C.
Posts
8,096
Likes
28,526
No way that an original dial would lack "automatic" on the dial. Keep in mind that during that time period, automatic watches were still a relative novelty, and no manufacturer would have chosen to hide the feature!
 
Bernhard J
Posts
632
Likes
2,134
No rule without exception. In have a Tissot PR 516, new old stock, mint, and clearly original all the way. But the dial does not say "Automatic", although a cal. 784 (automatic) is fitted. There are, however, identical dials and cases, but with the "Automatic" inscription, just from another production run.

So the missing "Automatic" on the instant dial seems to be strong evidence, but imo alone is no absolute proof.

Best, Bernhard
 
Tony C.
Posts
8,096
Likes
28,526
Bernhard J Bernhard J
In have a Tissot PR 516, new old stock, mint, and clearly original all the way

Your Tissot is not analogous, as it was manufactured at the earliest in the '60s, when the novelty of automatic movements had largely passed. Can you provide a single, compelling example of an automatic manufactured in the '40s through late '50s without the dial designation?
 
Bernhard J
Posts
632
Likes
2,134
Nothing easier than that. Look at the Harwoods, I do not know a single example WITH the dial designation "automatic" ... 😎😉
 
Tony C.
Posts
8,096
Likes
28,526
Good point! 👍

Any examples from major brands?
 
Bernhard J
Posts
632
Likes
2,134
Not instantly. Aside the fact, that any specific example might be argued as a redial. 😁
 
CaptainWinsor
Posts
1,986
Likes
3,558
Bernhard J Bernhard J
No rule without exception. In have a Tissot PR 516, new old stock, mint, and clearly original all the way. But the dial does not say "Automatic", although a cal. 784 (automatic) is fitted. There are, however, identical dials and cases, but with the "Automatic" inscription, just from another production run.

So the missing "Automatic" on the instant dial seems to be strong evidence, but imo alone is no absolute proof.

Best, Bernhard

I have never seen a Zenith bumper without the word automatic. The watch is not legitimate since the case has been swapped out and the case number and serial don’t line up
 
Tony C.
Posts
8,096
Likes
28,526
DirtyDozen12 DirtyDozen12
Here's one: Patek Philippe ref. 2526.

Good example, and explicable, as PP typically employed understated dial designs, and did not require overt marketing for their relatively small, exclusive client base.
 
DirtyDozen12
Posts
2,820
Likes
4,924
Tony C. Tony C.
Good example, and explicable, as PP typically employed understated dial designs, and did not require overt marketing for their relatively small, exclusive client base.
Agreed. I am struggling to come up with other examples. Even V&C adorned their dials with "Automatic" when applicable.
 
CaptainWinsor
Posts
1,986
Likes
3,558
Zenith, I believe, was the first bumper automatic with central seconds. The first cal 133 always had automatic on the dial, same with the 133.8. I’ve not seen enough examples of the cal 71 to say that definitively but I think Zenith wouldn’t put out some pieces without that on the dial. This was a company who had won the Neufchâtel Observatory award 5 years straight and was very proud of their achievements. I’ll post a pic of what I believe the dial should look like with a serial number that high
 
DTMwatch
Posts
204
Likes
344
Interesting topic and I appreciate all of the insights. My cal. 71 dial has the automatic inscription on it. I too have not seen any without it when looking at these great Zeniths from the 40s and 50s. However, I am no expert.
IMG_0052.jpeg
 
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

kaplan

A New Scam Ring On Catawiki - START CLAIMS + REQUEST REFUNDS

kaplan Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
kaplan
kaplan
Posts
18
Views
6K
Johannes11

Unusual Longines on catawiki

Johannes11 Longines Watches
Mark020
Mark020
Posts
20
Views
4K
Canuck

Zenith bumper calibre 133.8

Canuck Zenith Watches
Deafboy
Deafboy
Posts
22
Views
8K
duffy7

Constellation de luxe 2782 on Catawiki

duffy7 Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
duffy7
duffy7
Posts
0
Views
856
vicakers

Has anyone bought anything good on Catawiki?

vicakers Open Discussion
Bernhard J
Bernhard J
Posts
27
Views
4K
Olga Z

Omega Constellation on Catawiki Fake or Genuine?

Olga Z Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
optsdan
optsdan
Posts
52
Views
8K