I’ve gone through a couple bottles of the Offerman. It’s interesting, and the youth comes through. I still prefer the 16 though.
So do I. The 16 is classic Islay. Dry with a little hint orange peel The Offerman has that rich sweetness, dried nuts and figs. I also noticed that it’s peatier than the 16. The 16 peaty nose seems to have “melted” into the scotch. Both delicious but the 16 is my favourite of all. Sadly, becoming very difficult to get.
“
Oh my….forgot about my all time favourite! It’s become onubtainium or unaffordable. My late dad and I polished off my last bottle a few years ago. It’s become an intense but distant memory.
You and I would get along fine!👍