In this case I would also go for the sub...

 

Ugh, both a beauty, great patina <3, but I will have to go with Rolex.

 

Big triangle and sword hands combo make it a win over a very handsome sub.

 

The one without the date. I hate watches with a date window

 

Rolex in this case

 

The sub without doubt. Those guilt ones are crazy especially in this condition

 

If equal condition I go for the Seamaster but the patina is a little too much so I end up with the sub.

 

Seamaster because I already own the Rolex.

 

Rolex because the condition relative to other Subs is much better than the Seamaster relative to other Seamasters.

Patina on the Seamaster is a bit too much, and prefer the no-date version (as has previously been said).

Sub has a nice lightly ghosted bezel that still has its pip, good even patina, and nice gilt dial.

Out of curiosity, are these being offered for anywhere near the same price?

 

Definitely the sub , the Seamaster looks too far gone for me .

 

Sub

 

Omega. Sword hands and I don't like the blobs on the Rolex.

 

The blob? Did you even look at the pic in the OP?

 

thanks folks ! wearing the sub on the jubilee bracelet !

 

Marvelous, enjoy!

 

Sub for me.

 

Ignoring the financial value aspect I am leaning slightly toward the SM300....