Forums Latest Auctions Members

Which one would you prefer ?

  1. sthai

    sthai Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    9
    Likes
    37
    cooljme likes this.
  2. NobodySpecial

    NobodySpecial Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    13
    Likes
    92
    Eesh that’s rough. I prefer the seamaster, but if somebody was offering, I’d take the Rolex
     
  3. eugeneandresson

    eugeneandresson Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    2,432
    Likes
    5,919
    2 liner vs 1 liner...I thought less is more, and less lines always wins :)
     
  4. asrnj77

    asrnj77 Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    508
    Likes
    479
    Both nice but the lume of the subs always seem to hold up better than the seamasters. I'd go with the sub on this one.
     
    Tony C. and michael22 like this.
  5. NobodySpecial

    NobodySpecial Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    13
    Likes
    92
    Yea picked up my first seamaster today, it’s a 1986 and the lume is almost non existent
     
  6. vienna

    vienna Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    208
    Likes
    373
    Of course the one with the bigger triangle.
    kind regards Max
     
  7. rob#1

    rob#1 Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    579
    Likes
    699
    Sword hands and a more detailed bezel - Seamaster for me :D
     
  8. blufinz52

    blufinz52 Hears dead people, not watch rotors. Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    1,475
    Likes
    2,186
    Rolex all day!
     
  9. Nathan1967

    Nathan1967 Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    1,250
    Likes
    2,409
    Well as it’s your treat @sthai i’ll have that nice Rolex please! Nice of you to ask by the way....super generous.

    I love a Seamaster 300 but not with a date......it’s somehow just wrong on that watch.
     
    DaveK likes this.
  10. mzinski

    mzinski Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    86
    Likes
    131
    I’d go with the Seamaster. Sure, the other one is a Rolex but it looks like a pretty average example.
     
  11. BradleyJ.

    BradleyJ. Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    453
    Likes
    354
    Omega lugs for the win
     
  12. KingCrouchy

    KingCrouchy Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    952
    Likes
    3,442
    Seamaster, but if I could chose I would take your Car in the Avatar.;):thumbsup:
     
    Nathan1967 likes this.
  13. Dan S

    Dan S Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    4,344
    Likes
    10,933
    I'll take the Sub, no question. If it were a straight-lug SM300, my decision would be more difficult.
     
  14. JwRosenthal

    JwRosenthal Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    2,503
    Likes
    4,343
    Sub- that seamaster’s Dial is a bit past my point of wabi-sabi and there are plenty out there in better shape.
     
    Donn Chambers likes this.
  15. gostang9

    gostang9 Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    2,373
    Likes
    6,149
    Me too. That Rolex all day every day over that Seamaster.
     
    blufinz52 likes this.
  16. kingsrider

    kingsrider Thank you Sir! May I have another? Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    2,051
    Likes
    4,207
    The Sub. No dates are my preference and unless I am mistaken the sub is more valuable.
     
    DaveK, noelekal and blufinz52 like this.
  17. redpcar

    redpcar Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    2,192
    Likes
    3,130
    If they are the same price, Rolex.
     
  18. alam

    alam Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    7,392
    Likes
    15,411
    Sub for me please.
     
  19. BlackTalon

    BlackTalon Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    3,015
    Likes
    4,419
    I'm not a Rolex person, but the date window kills the Seamaster for me. I would go with the Sub.
     
    Vitezi and Nathan1967 like this.
  20. Henneth

    Henneth Oct 10, 2019

    Posts
    134
    Likes
    510
    I would take the sub, sell it and get myself a straight lug seamaster or a Tudor snowflake... ;)