Watches gaining time when walking

Posts
198
Likes
250
A slightly weird issue here. Two 1960s watches I have, a Seamaster De Ville with a 552 movement and a Constellation with a 751 movement, were serviced recently by a local watchmaker. I hadn't worn them for any extended periods before servicing. With the micro-adjuster screw I've managed to regulate them to within two or three seconds a day, as long as I'm just wearing them about the house or they are off the wrist (they don't seem particularly sensitive to positional differences).

However, If I go for a 30 minute walk both watches will have gained about 15 seconds when I get back... They will immediately then settle back into near perfect time-keeping (except for being 15s ahead of course).

I've seen other threads in various places reporting similar issues, and theories put forward include overbanking (unlikely in both watches presumably?), and interactions between the rythmic nature of walking and the periodicity of the balance spring ocsillation...

My King Seikos don't do this, but they are 8 bps movements rather than 5.5.

Is this just something I have to live with due to the particular nature of these movements, or is something wrong/fixable? It could be quite a major issue if I was wearing one of the watches on a long walk (e.g. hiking), assuming it was linear with time (could the watch gain several minutes?).
 
Posts
20,996
Likes
47,999
Are you moving at a substantial fraction of the speed of light, by any chance? 😕
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
Are you moving at a substantial fraction of the speed of light, by any chance? 😕
Ha ha, nope!

I'm a moderately fast walker though, about 4 mph
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,792
When people walk, their arms swing. Some more than others. Yours might well be swinging at just the right frequency to counter the watch's equilibrium.
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
When people walk, their arms swing. Some more than others. Yours might well be swinging at just the right frequency to counter the watch's equilibrium.
Yup, I read a suggestion along these lines somewhere else.

Sometimes I walk with my hands in my pockets, sometimes not. I'll experiment to see if that makes a difference!

Idea - if that is the cause, would it be positionally dependent? E.g if I strapped the watch crown-up on my wrist when walking, might that sort it?
 
Posts
2,312
Likes
6,628
Are you moving at a substantial fraction of the speed of light, by any chance? 😕
Wonder what would happen if the OP walked backwards...
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
Wonder what would happen if the OP walked backwards...
Don't think I could walk backwards at 4mph for 30 minutes.. 😀
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,792
Yup, I read a suggestion along these lines somewhere else.

Sometimes I walk with my hands in my pockets, sometimes not. I'll experiment to see if that makes a difference!

Idea - if that is the cause, would it be positionally dependent? E.g if I strapped the watch crown-up on my wrist when walking, might that sort it?
Try wearing it on the inside of your wrist instead,
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
Worth a go! Not least because it's easy to do (doesn't require unstrapping).
 
Posts
14,317
Likes
41,261
Do you “power walk” occasionally, with exaggerated arm motion? Might the gain happen at these times? Maybe wear a watch that isn’t affected, during your walks.
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
Do you “power walk” occasionally, with exaggerated arm motion? Might the gain happen at these times? Maybe wear a watch that isn’t affected, during your walks.
Not really.. I mean, I'm a fast walker, but I always walk the same way (unless I'm with people who are walking more slowly). And I walk most days, so it's not really practical to have watches for non-walking days..😉
 
Posts
16,741
Likes
47,363
Wear one and place the other in your pocket. Do this for 2 days alternating the watches and report back please….interested if it’s a arm swinging thing or not.
 
Posts
1,596
Likes
3,713
Surprised no one has suggested that do your walk anti-clockwise today, perhaps you would lose the 15 seconds you gained yesterday?
 
Posts
198
Likes
250
Wear one and place the other in your pocket. Do this for 2 days alternating the watches and report back please….interested if it’s a arm swinging thing or not.
Good idea, will do (or something similar).