Watch winders are a waste of space. Discuss.

Posts
4,968
Likes
15,177
Yes it's the companion to the Travel Clock and called the "Travel Winder" 😁
I regularly travel with my Emotional Support Hamster, and bought a really nice watch attachment for its exercise wheel, so it does the winding for me. Win win!

 
Posts
67
Likes
255
I’m sure there are those who understandably simply like the pride and theatre of displaying their well researched/sought/obtained/hard earned collections and/or keeping them moving immediately ‘ready to go’ upon rotation when required.

Personally to my failing minimalistic sensibilities (‘watches’) I feel winders are clutter, a waste of space & energy, unnecessarily adding to the wear and tear of movements without receiving the benefit/pleasure of actually wearing it. Rather than each having it’s own emotive meaning/theatre when setting, winding or shaking as required.
Edited:
 
Posts
504
Likes
1,948
I’m sure there are those who understandably simply like the pride and theatre of displaying their well researched/sought/obtained/hard earned collections and/or keeping them moving immediately ‘ready to go’ upon rotation when required.

Personally to my failing minimalistic sensibilities (‘watches’) I feel winders are clutter, a waste of space & energy, unnecessarily adding to the wear and tear of movements without receiving the benefit/pleasure of actually wearing it. Rather than each having it’s own emotive meaning/theatre when setting, winding or shaking as required.

I kind of have to agree with this.

What value is a watch that has been wound that no one is looking at?

IMHO, a watch should only have "to work" when someone can benefit from knowing the current time.

.
 
Posts
103
Likes
265
Does a winder reduce wear on the crown and winding mechanism? Friday night I put my Rolex Explorer on the winder because I like to wear my SMP or PO on the weekend and it won’t make it till Monday morning.
 
Posts
334
Likes
738
Does a winder reduce wear on the crown and winding mechanism? Friday night I put my Rolex Explorer on the winder because I like to wear my SMP or PO on the weekend and it won’t make it till Monday morning.

Well, the winder just turns your watch around, the rotor still spins, so the wear on the winding mechanism is the same. You shouldn't worry about stuff like that though. As for wear on the crown, I don't know what you mean by that.

Nice Angelfish by the way, definitely one of my favorite aquarium fish.
 
Posts
362
Likes
564
Depends how many watches you have and whether you ever get frustrated by deciding to wear a watch last minute and set it in a rush. Also, for my non screw down crown models I don’t like to continually keep winding them manually as I was told it wears the crown gasket a little each time.

^ This is the ideal. But in reality I don’t use a winder because I haven’t got one. Unless I spend mega bucks I’ll never have enough winders for watches.
 
Posts
1,691
Likes
1,648
Please buy a watchwinder from this poor girl so she can buy a button for her jacket. And a shirt. And a bra...

A towel to dry her hair.
 
Posts
6,077
Likes
44,983
Sort of like leaving your car running all the time because you can't be bothered to start it.

No watch winders need apply here. Watches are not displayed, but rather locked in a safe. I'm not fond of date features anyway and will simply set the date when a watch having that feature gets the call to wear.

This is not hard.
 
Posts
1,061
Likes
5,796
Please buy a watchwinder from this poor girl so she can buy a button for her jacket. And a shirt. And a bra...
I want to say that someone should leave out a bowl of water for that Camel but I won't.
 
Posts
292
Likes
986
I did hear an argument from someone who used winders that they were ensuring oil was always well distributed, preventing damage and wear on the movement. Not sure of the truth in this?. I get that turning over a mechanical car on a regular basis gets oil back up from the sump and into the working parts. Left idle too long gravity will drain all the oil to the sump and you risk engine damage or seizure. On my understanding there is no sump in a watch and oil just sits in the movement and if it should drain down, it would be a matter of millimetres. Might be one for the watchmakers this, is a movement less subject to wear if constantly wound or is it better left idle and wound as required?.
 
Posts
1,541
Likes
3,350
I did hear an argument from someone who used winders that they were ensuring oil was always well distributed, preventing damage and wear on the movement. Not sure of the truth in this?. I get that turning over a mechanical car on a regular basis gets oil back up from the sump and into the working parts. Left idle too long gravity will drain all the oil to the sump and you risk engine damage or seizure. On my understanding there is no sump in a watch and oil just sits in the movement and if it should drain down, it would be a matter of millimetres. Might be one for the watchmakers this, is a movement less subject to wear if constantly wound or is it better left idle and wound as required?.
I believe in the old days when watches were lubricated with natural oils such as animal fat they would dry out but these days synthetic lubes are used and this is not a risk. Happy to be corrected.
 
Posts
5,265
Likes
24,280
is a movement less subject to wear if constantly wound or is it better left idle and wound as required?.

Archer answered this here.
 
Posts
5,265
Likes
24,280
I believe in the old days when watches were lubricated with natural oils such as animal fat they would dry out but these days synthetic lubes are used and this is not a risk. Happy to be corrected.
This post from Archer explains what happens to modern day oils.