Vintage Renaissance, but where's the tritium?

Posts
603
Likes
2,567
Given the vintage fever over the past 5 years, which the companies are getting behind more and more, why haven't any of them offered tritium lume? I understand the current offering's homage nature and wanting to attract the broader non-WIS audience, but the main detractor for many is that the Luminova won't patinate and the watch will be forever as it is (barring catastrophe). Their current solution is faux-patina, which many scoff at. I wonder, if things continue, if companies will start to offer some pieces with an option for tritium. I'm not sure if the switch away from it had anything to do with radiation (like with the radium-> tritium switch) and compliance with a regulation or if it was purely for the better luminescence. I think it would be great to see this as an option.

[Not sure if this has been talked about before within another thread or elsewhere (vintage forum or open forum) so please direct me to that thread if it has.]
 
Posts
33
Likes
37
As I see it; the upper echelon brands manufacture watches in 2 main categories:

1. Modern design incorporating elements from the past but maintaining a very contemporary look
2. Vintage inspired; where the look is very much in keeping with a vintage piece but all the materials and engineering are contemporary.

Either way; tritium is an antiquated material. Super-lumiNova can produce the same visual effect as a T-lume that has patina but still enable luminescence to be retained in perpetuity - hence it is an objectively better choice.
 
Posts
270
Likes
970
It simply is outlawed, at least in some parts of the world, like the EU. By radiation protection laws, in order to use radioactive luminous compouds you would have to prove that this is neccessary for functional reason and cannot be substituted w/ non radioacative luminous paint. This is obviously not possible for luxury items. And given the performance and edurance of modern SL lume also difficult for professional instruments - Panerai sailed under this flag for a while but ceased to do so in ~2006.
Edited:
 
Posts
2,510
Likes
3,729
It's not faux-patina, it's simply aesthetically pleasing Super-Luminova. ;-)
 
Posts
1,306
Likes
1,456
Tritium is also one of the elements that requires a significant amount of administrative paperwork and regulatory oversight to use.
 
Posts
17,746
Likes
26,929
Tritium is also one of the elements that requires a significant amount of administrative paperwork and regulatory oversight to use.
Someone does Tritium dials still. But they are tritium tubes that are sealed.
 
Posts
52
Likes
27
All Ball watches use the tritium tubes too.

Must be ok because it's all sealed.
 
Posts
16,754
Likes
47,412
Done a bit of reading last night and they only use gas in the tubes which is not as bad