Bulldozer
·In reality, it's not difficult to scratch or chip - I see watches with damaged sapphire crystals all the time.
And yes, in some cases scratches can be polished out, but have you ever done it? I have, and I can assure you it's not something that is done quickly or easily. In many cases the labour for polishing out a scratch would cost more than a new crystal would. For deep scratches you end up with a very distorted surface on the crystal also.
If you prefer sapphire, that's your choice, but each material has advantages and drawbacks. Personally I have watches with both sapphire and mineral crystal, and for the Speedmaster I would not want the sapphire version - it just doesn't look as good to me.
Cheers, Al
Thats fair enough and I too have all 3 types of crystal in the few watches that I own, the bottom line is that Sapphire crystal is the hardest at 9 on the Mohs scale and the hardest to scratch mineral crystal is next hardest to scratch and plexiglass of hesalite is softest and very easy to scratch or mark.
If I were going to Climb Everest or be in the field like in the military using the watch as a tool watch then maybe plexiglass or Hesalite would be a wise choice.
If I were going to simply wear the tool watch as a desk diver etc then I like Sapphire crystal best due to its clarity and toughness for little bumps and bangs that it may encounter.
This is simply a discussion as there is no right or wrong, only personal preference of what we like so each to our own but the bottom line is that Sapphire is a lot harder to scratch the way most people wear their watches and Diamond paste will take out most scratches on it.
One thing that I believe is that the price of Plexiglass or Hesalite crystal will quickly begin to rise. Time will tell.