Speedmaster 145.012 Authenticity Check: Dial & Lume Issues

Posts
762
Likes
1,739
It's just not that nice. Lume plots aren't attractive and the hands are grotty.
 
Posts
585
Likes
748
If you're ok with reluming it, I suppose the bezel is nice, and maybe the case but hard to tell with those blown out photos...
 
Posts
243
Likes
291
Not sure if it is an artefact from the photo but the 10 in the minute subdial looks very strange.
 
Posts
243
Likes
291
If you're ok with reluming it, I suppose the bezel is nice, and maybe the case but hard to tell with those blown out photos...
Not to divert from the thread, but how much do you think reluming effects the value of a non-collector grade watch? I am considering having it done to a watch myself.

Personally I don’t see it as a negative, but I have seen a lot of comments implying it is.
 
Posts
24,838
Likes
55,263
The main issues are the obvious cosmetic ones.

Not to divert from the thread, but how much do you think reluming effects the value of a non-collector grade watch? I am considering having it done to a watch myself.
If the original lume is almost gone or extremely ugly, I don't think re-luming hurts the value at all.
 
Posts
762
Likes
1,739
Here's a relumed watch with a refinished case, a spiralwinder insert and an uncle seiko bracelet. Looks way better than a scruffy worn out watch to me.

 
Posts
75
Likes
26
Not sure if it is an artefact from the photo but the 10 in the minute subdial looks very strange.
The 10 is damaged actually
 
Posts
243
Likes
291
The main issues are the obvious cosmetic ones.


If the original lume is almost gone or extremely ugly, I don't think re-luming hurts the value at all.
That was my assumption as well, but thanks for confirming! I guess the key is just to get it tastefully relumed rather than a too strong colour.
 
Posts
243
Likes
291
The 10 is damaged actually
Ah. Then I wouldn’t have really considered it as to me that would be too distracting.
 
Posts
3,679
Likes
8,014
I don’t think you missed anything here. Keep hunting
 
Posts
2,671
Likes
2,856
Anyway, thanks for the feedback, but the watch was already sold by now for 5600 euros.
That is no deal for this one IMO, you're fortunate someone grabbed it before you did something stupid (like pay that much for that watch 😁 ).
 
Posts
761
Likes
916
Why not look to the private sales forum, a couple of very nice Speedmasters for sale right now..
 
Posts
585
Likes
748
Not to divert from the thread, but how much do you think reluming effects the value of a non-collector grade watch? I am considering having it done to a watch myself.

Personally I don’t see it as a negative, but I have seen a lot of comments implying it is.
For a non-collector grade watch, I don't think it hurts the value and may even slightly help it. I used Horoluma.com, who uses "vintage" pigments (purportedly not luminova based) and really like the result.