Seamaster 300 ref. 2913-5 from 1958

Posts
54
Likes
27
So... are you saying the OP lies about getting an offer or? And as he/she does not seem to be willing to part with it - why imply it?
I can understand where they’re coming from, I was surprised myself. But I indeed don’t want to sell and have no interest in knowing the value of the watch besides to compare to the prices to fix it. Already purchased a movement and my watchmaker is getting his research done so when he gets my watch, he knows where he’s going, so I’m all set, I believe!

I have to say, I’ve had many unsolicited offers indeed ranging from nothing to those high prices, and the watchmakers who I talked to, who know I have no interest in selling and weren’t on a market for one of these anyway, always gave very high values also, always in the same ballpark. That’s why I’m so confused and asked here!
 
Posts
2,597
Likes
5,656
I reckon here is as good a place as any to get accurate estimates on the value, but of course there are always others who will significantly overvalue or undervalue compared to the majority. I’d guess, that if a vote was cast that the most common band for value here would be $4-5k. I think that’s mainly down to the good condition of the case and bezel. I’d also guess the second most common would be the one under rather than the one over. The strong dollar at the moment does impact my view though.

So for the OP, I’d certainly have no worries getting it sorted as I’m sure from your comments you picked it up for a fraction of these values. Were the watchmakers all estimating values above this range, and even in the region of the strongest offer that you had ? I ask as I would genuinely be surprised, as it would men that I’m clearly off on my understanding of CK2913 prices.
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
I reckon here is as good a place as any to get accurate estimates on the value, but of course there are always others who will significantly overvalue or undervalue compared to the majority. I’d guess, that if a vote was cast that the most common band for value here would be $4-5k. I think that’s mainly down to the good condition of the case and bezel. I’d also guess the second most common would be the one under rather than the one over. The strong dollar at the moment does impact my view though.

So for the OP, I’d certainly have no worries getting it sorted as I’m sure from your comments you picked it up for a fraction of these values. Were the watchmakers all estimating values above this range, and even in the region of the strongest offer that you had ? I ask as I would genuinely be surprised, as it would men that I’m clearly off on my understanding of CK2913 prices.
Hey there! I’m getting it sorted so I can wear it daily. The estimates they gave me, for a very good example, were absolutely astronomical, and those are dudes who sell Paul Newmans and Royal Oak Tourbillon etc, as well as vintage Seamaster 300 themselves, none of them had one remotely as early as mine. For my example still, they still valued it quite above that offer when in working order, which it will be in a few weeks, as I have a movement underway.
 
Posts
2,597
Likes
5,656
Yes mint examples can command a premium, especially from dealers and the big auction houses. Maybe they’d try and sell north of 8.5k, but it’d be more interesting to know what they’d offer. Mine is actually a 2913-3 (forgive my previous memory fail) and from these numbers I should probably sell it !
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
Yes mint examples can command a premium, especially from dealers and the big auction houses. Maybe they’d try and sell north of 8.5k, but it’d be more interesting to know what they’d offer. Mine is actually a 2913-3 (forgive my previous memory fail) and from these numbers I should probably sell it !
I gotta tell ya, I’m really not familiar with the market for these watches, which is why I’m so curious on what everything says and things, even though I’m not selling. If you love your watch as much as I love mine, keep it if you can!
 
Posts
23,451
Likes
52,103
Yes mint examples can command a premium, especially from dealers and the big auction houses. Maybe they’d try and sell north of 8.5k, but it’d be more interesting to know what they’d offer. Mine is actually a 2913-3 (forgive my previous memory fail) and from these numbers I should probably sell it !

Maybe you can soak your dial in water for a while and then get the contact info of the guy who offered $8.5k for the OP watch.
 
Posts
7,805
Likes
35,448
So... are you saying the OP lies about getting an offer or? And as he/she does not seem to be willing to part with it - why imply it?

No, I wasn't impling anything, I meant I find it hard to believe that the offer was a real/serious/firm offer of $8.5K.

IMHO anybody with an understanding of this reference who was going to undertake a restoration would also understand relative costs for both the parts and as a completed watch and as i explained I don't feel the numbers add up on this one if beginning with an $8,5k initial buy price, hence my doubts.
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
Maybe you can soak your dial in water for a while and then get the contact info of the guy who offered $8.5k for the OP watch.
Good idea as any
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
No, I wasn't impling anything, I meant I find it hard to believe that the offer was a real/serious/firm offer of $8.5K.

IMHO anybody with an understanding of this reference who was going to undertake a restoration would also understand relative costs for both the parts and as a completed watch and as i explained I don't feel the numbers add up on this one if beginning with an $8,5k initial buy price, hence my doubts.
What you’re saying makes absolute sense, but I’m not going to dig any further on their side!
 
Posts
665
Likes
772
I don’t have a clue, but possibly

You should ask him. Maybe he has the spare parts that you need and would be willing to sell them to you.
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
You should ask him. Maybe he has the spare parts that you need and would be willing to sell them to you.
I already have everything I need, I’m very excited!
 
Posts
665
Likes
772
I already have everything I need, I’m very excited!

I think I know the place where you got that watch:



And it's great that you are excited about it NOW but don't forget the three rules:

- No water (violated)
- No bright light (violated)
- Don't wear it after midnight
 
Posts
3,938
Likes
45,349
No, I wasn't impling anything, I meant I find it hard to believe that the offer was a real/serious/firm offer of $8.5K.

IMHO anybody with an understanding of this reference who was going to undertake a restoration would also understand relative costs for both the parts and as a completed watch and as i explained I don't feel the numbers add up on this one if beginning with an $8,5k initial buy price, hence my doubts.

Nice to hear! It might be a language thing on my side - hence my "or?" I just felt a bit sorry for the chap as he/she clearly is very happy and entusiastic about the watch and also is a newcomer here - if you were calling him a liar. And you did not - everything is good. Sorry that I were calling you out wrongly.

I am mostly lurking nowadays and/but I have noticed a harsher tone towards beginners/new members lately. I got carried away.
 
Posts
10,305
Likes
16,126
Nice to hear! It might be a language thing on my side - hence my "or?" I just felt a bit sorry for the chap as he/she clearly is very happy and entusiastic about the watch and also is a newcomer here - if you were calling him a liar. And you did not - everything is good. Sorry that I were calling you out wrongly.

I am mostly lurking nowadays and/but I have noticed a harsher tone towards beginners/new members lately. I got carried away.
So that aside, you believe someone would happily part with $8.5k for this basket case then? I'm calling you out if you think it is worth that.

A harsh tone is not a good thing I agree, but to support unrealistic valuations is dangerous as it sets a precedent so a little tough love is necessary occasionally. Such as here.
Edited:
 
Posts
3,938
Likes
45,349
So that aside, you believe someone would happily part with $8.5k for this basket case then? I'm calling you out if you think it is worth that.
..snip....

Sorry - I have no horse in that race. On a general level I believe things are worth what someone is willing to pay - and they may take informed/wise or uninformed/not so wise decisions.
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
I think I know the place where you got that watch:



And it's great that you are excited about it NOW but don't forget the three rules:

- No water (violated)
- No bright light (violated)
- Don't wear it after midnight
I understood the thing about wearing it after midnight when the watch tried to punch me
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
Great news gang! The movement has finally arrived… and it works!!! Also looks waaay better thank thought!
 
Posts
3,532
Likes
7,563
please don´t touch these movements with bare fingers - not a good idea...
 
Posts
23,451
Likes
52,103
please don´t touch these movements with bare fingers - not a good idea...

Maybe he wants to use it for a coin flip.
 
Posts
54
Likes
27
please don´t touch these movements with bare fingers - not a good idea...
No worries, at my watchmaker now, it’s safe there