Risk of reversal of a received bank transfer

Posts
15,598
Likes
46,465
I’ve had similar things happen to me. The bank I deal with diarizes the payment for about 10 days, before the funds are deposited into my account and are available to me. I’ve never had a client back out of a deal, the payment cancelled, and I’m left sucking a hind t—.
 
Posts
3,155
Likes
34,346
Early in my tenure here I purchased a watch for cash from an established member F2F, we walked to my bank to withdraw, then I walked him to his bank to deposit for safety sake. In US amounts under $10,000 do not trigger bank reporting.
 
Posts
2,569
Likes
3,768
hank you for this distinction. So how can i tell whether i am receiving a bank transfer or a wire transfer?
Are you sure you work for a bank? Isn’t there anyone at your bank you could talk to, rather than random people on the internet? Sorry, but I just had to ask.
Edited:
 
Posts
678
Likes
683
What country are you located in?
Why not just conduct the transaction at your bank and have him bring cash to deposit with the bank teller right there on site?
 
Posts
2,651
Likes
3,106
I've heard this happen but not experienced this or got first hand experience

If you live in a country where bank accounts can not overdraft, just moving the money to another account is protection enough
 
Posts
215
Likes
305
Fraud system earlier: A (Germany) offers car for the amount X, B (UK) agrees - payment in advance - car will be picked up later, A says: OK, B transfers X plus 4000. A reports: 4000 too much. B says: please refer 4000 back. A does this, B then cancels the amount X. "clever" action back then.
No chance to get that amount back, all covered by the (bank-) rules

That is truly terrifying.
Has this now been identified and closed off?
 
Posts
5,082
Likes
15,706
In Italy we have the "instant transfer"; once sent it is impossible to reverse it.
Even a transfer to a branch of the same bank is irreversible.
Transfers between different banks can be canceled before 4pm.

Canada has the e-Transfer system, probably like yours. Free, instant, password protected and not reversible. Plus it establishes a trail between two legitimate bank accounts.
 
Posts
2,970
Likes
6,180
That is truly terrifying.
Has this now been identified and closed off?
I don´t know. That was invented 😉 and possible in UK (years ago).
 
Posts
18,088
Likes
37,750
I acted as a middleman for a European member purchasing an expensive watch in Australia.
He transferred approx AUD$25K to my bank account.
I met the seller next day at my bank. Inspected the watch, shook on the deal, walked into the bank and transferred the money to his account.
I then sent the watch to the buyer via a circuitous route which we shall not discuss.

Thankfully the buyer didn't reverse the $25K transfer.
But then again, I knew he wouldn't
He's a trusted member here and he has trusted me on a number of occasions.

So..........buy the buyer, or buy the seller depending on what side of the deal you stand.
 
Posts
29,826
Likes
77,189
Canada has the e-Transfer system, probably like yours. Free, instant, password protected and not reversible. Plus it establishes a trail between two legitimate bank accounts.

It is reversible in some circumstances. If you have it set-up for auto-deposit, someone can claim that it was sent in error, and have it reversed. If you use a password protected manual deposit, it can't be reversed as this implies it was sent with intent and the receiver has the password the sender set.
 
Posts
233
Likes
180
In the UK:
Domestic transfers:
Wire transfer, done and dusted, no chance of getting your money back.
Bank transfer, you have a tight window. Providing you alert your bank and the receiving bank quickly enough you have a chance. Varies by bank.
International transfers:
Very complicated and chances and outcomes vary by destination country.
As said frequently on here, 'buy the seller'.....oh, and cash is king!