Refinishing advice

Posts
498
Likes
407
I’d like to start with a disclaimer that I’m aware in many cases polishing is regarded as wrong or a bad thing to do.

I wanted some advice in this case though. I have a very clean ref 2849; the dial is exceptional in both condition and type (being two tone with interesting markers). The watch has clearly been looked after over it’s life.

However the lugs definitely show their age; the chamfers are still present, but have been softened, and the 9 o clock side of the bezel is more worn than the other indicating to me that it has potentially been worn by a sleeve passing over it over the years. As such I feel I can venture to say it has not been ‘polished’ in the past.

I am considering getting the case sympathetically refinished, so that the sharp lines of the chamfers return. I am thinking of Simon Freese who I know does good work. However I’d like to get some opinions on here before I do anything.

Thanks!

 
Posts
3,194
Likes
13,864
I wouldn't bother. It's a vintage watch that proudly wears it's 70 years of age. Why remove that charm?
 
Posts
498
Likes
407
I wouldn't bother. It's a vintage watch that proudly wears it's 70 years of age. Why remove that charm?
Fair enough! The more I think the more it might not be a great idea; the proportions could be changed slightly, and you can’t undo that kind of thing.
 
Posts
3,233
Likes
12,697
Fair enough! The more I think the more it might not be a great idea; the proportions could be changed slightly, and you can’t undo that kind of thing.

You can give it to someone who does laser wielding. I’m not sure if that’s what you were intending Simon Freese to do, but it’ll basically return a sharp (or sharper) as new case, same proportions. If done well, that is.
Personally, with this case, I wouldn’t bother.
 
Posts
3,773
Likes
20,190
I'd leave alone. It's a beauty as it is.
 
Posts
9,960
Likes
15,640
I’m not against refinishing a case on principle, and indeed the laser welding then recutting route would be the one to take, but I don’t think that is as bad you think. All 2846/8/9s have a bit of lug wear as they are all very old and were used as tool watches. It’s your watch and don’t let anyone tell you what is right or wrong, but I wonder whether this one is bad enough to warrant it.
 
Posts
498
Likes
407
Well it seems the consensus is strong here! Thanks all for your replies and advice. And thanks too for the compliments - it’s a looker!
 
Posts
13,164
Likes
52,298
Leave that lovely watch alone. Movement service only.
 
Posts
2,531
Likes
2,923
I'm pro professional restoration as well, but it needs to be a lost cause being restored by laser welding and then matching the original factory finish

For example cases is with rust pits should be universally accepted, I have not yet seen anyone who enjoys rust
A second situation is cases intentionally damaged by previous owners, for example polished cases

Your case looks beautiful though, and all original

Another thing to consider is whether the watch will be a display item or whether it's going to be worn, if it's going to be worn, it's going to become naturally shiny again anyway, so might as well keep the microns in place
 
Posts
21,834
Likes
49,532
I don't generally think it makes to get involved in that sort of restoration for a relatively common watch in this price range. The current condition is appealing, and I would happily live with it. If I were unhappy with the condition, I'd sell it and buy a better one. If we were talking about a $5,000+ watch, or a watch that is very hard to find, it might make more sense to think about restoring it.
Edited:
 
Posts
498
Likes
407
Thanks again for your replies. I have decided I won’t do anything; and incidentally had a reply from Simon to say he wouldn’t do anything to it because of how localised it would be, and therefore he doesn’t think it would benefit the look of the case.
 
Posts
1,074
Likes
3,738
Rarely has any thread served to unite opinion on this forum as this one has.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,793
Rarely has any thread served to unite opinion on this forum as this one has.
My dissent is that it is his money and his watch, and he can do whatever he wants with it, including tossing it into the ocean.

That case can be refinished if you want to. Or not. Your choice. I personally do not care what your choice is!

But if you choose to, definitely find someone who is good at it. I had a CMW buff the living crap out of a stainless case without my permission... and it was really bad.
 
Posts
238
Likes
519
A shiny case with a charming dial wouldn’t look right. But if you decide to go that route I would recommend lewis watch co in Perth. Adam does amazing job on cases.
 
Posts
9,960
Likes
15,640
A shiny case with a charming dial wouldn’t look right. But if you decide to go that route I would recommend lewis watch co in Perth. Adam does amazing job on cases.

Unless you mean Perth Scotland, and I am pretty sure you don’t, that isn’t all that handy for a citizen of the UK