Pensioner who cancelled sale eBay is ordered to pay £11,600

Posts
2,648
Likes
4,503
Just yesterday, I picked up a eBay purchase ( a second hand transmission for my Ute)
I payed the seller in cash, as requested by the seller, it was also in my interest as if it wasn’t up to scratch, on inspection, I would’ve just walked away and not gone through all the palaver on getting my money back.
Anyway by the time I got home he’d canceled the sale with eBay, stating the the cancellation was due to a cancellation request by the buyer.
I had made no such request, and as I’d paid and taken the thing away with me. I’d say the sale is final.
Now obviously ol’ mate was doing the dirty on eBay by not paying fees, and not having a go at me.

The moral of this story is dodgy shit goes on all over eBay all the time, sometimes it’s aimed at the seller, sometimes it aimed at eBay and sometimes it’s aimed at the buyer. Some would argue that eBay aims dodgy shit at everyone.
But they have to calculate a win/loss ratio to come up with a formula of protection of both sellers and buyers without making the platform unworkable and overbearing for it’s users. They also have to protect themselves and their profits. ( I must add that they seem to do a better job at this) 😁
Now I don’t feel sorry for eBay having to go to all the trouble ( I’d take that sort of lucrative trouble on any day of the week and twice on Sundays)
But they’re never going to achieve perfection or anything vaguely near it, their machine is too big and unwieldily for this, but at least it is profitable! And that’s all they really give a shit about. Let’s face it’s that’s all most of their customers care about too.

It may not be just or fair, but the reality is that greed rules.

One bright note is that the transmission is already in the Ute and it runs like Phar Lap!
( all you non Aussie members will have to look that up)
 
Posts
6,455
Likes
49,759
"You say you haven't been the same since you had your little crash,
but you might feel better if I gave you some cash."

 
Posts
228
Likes
528
Who on earth would spend so much money on antiquated, obsolete, electromagnetic technology?

*checks watch*

 
Posts
12,877
Likes
22,267
EBay can be a nightmare. I once sold an item (not watch related) and the buyer asked for cash on collection.

I agree, the buyer collected, paid and went on their way. A few days later I received a dispute for ‘item not received’. I relied to eBay saying the seller collected and paid cash. They asked me for my proof of delivery/collection to which I replied I didn’t have any. As such I was forced to refund the buyer.

As a result I only ever ship via tracked and signed delivery on eBay. No collection, no economy delivery. Take it or leave it.
 
Posts
6,455
Likes
49,759
Hmmm...

The common denominator here seems to be Ebay.
 
Posts
2,648
Likes
4,503
Most items that are sign on delivery by Auspost are just left on the door step if no one is home…..especially it would seem it they’re valuable items such as a watch, but with cheap shit like watch batteries I always have to go to pick them up at the post office in order to sign for them 🤨
 
Posts
5,983
Likes
20,560
Who on earth would spend so much money on antiquated, obsolete, electromagnetic technology?

*checks watch*


Finally, a watch picture. And a beautiful one at that.

Now to search ebay for one just like it...
 
Posts
644
Likes
2,267
???? A German Court "ordered" a British Pensioner ( not longer in the EU jurisdiction ) to pay in Pounds ? How will that be enforced? The Buyer might have a Title. Maybe frame it and hang in the living room.... Daily Mail is not known for reliable, non sensationalist , accurate, non BS reporting.....
You're right about the daily black shirt.
If it isn't bashing the EU, the public sector, immigration, illegal or otherwise and Meghan Windsor it has nothing to say.
 
Posts
644
Likes
2,267
Hmmm...

The common denominator here seems to be Ebay.
But it's in the daily mail so may just be ::stirthepot:: and 🤮
 
Posts
644
Likes
2,267
It may surprise you, or 😉 not, to know that I read the daily mirror but their on line site is exactly the same as the daily black shirt.
The hatred for Meghan Windsor on there would almost do the black shirt proud 😡
I've not read the Echo for years but used to like their boxing coverage, amateur and pro.
 
Posts
643
Likes
978
I loathe the daily mail so much I've blocked it at the router. The mrs can't work out why the site doesn't work... I feign ignorance obviously. She's still none the wiser.

Not having that shite in my house. Not even to start the wood burner.
 
Posts
644
Likes
2,267
I loathe the daily mail so much I've blocked it at the router. The mrs can't work out why the site doesn't work... I feign ignorance obviously. She's still none the wiser.

Not having that shite in my house. Not even to start the wood burner.
I see all pensioners buying it and mentally shake my head.
I think they're slowly seeing what the Spaffer was all about though
 
Posts
4,693
Likes
17,769
Just to be clear the story and applicable rules around auctions on eBay do appear to be factually correct from multiples sources (I always cross check). We don’t want to cancel facts in our rush to be politically correct….. or do we ;0)
I guess it is the post fact Twitter war / sound bite war that sets policy across all political divides these days. Meanwhile the bureaucratic deep state ensures the big guns grind on with the money whatever while the rest argue in circles….

Just a note for people to be aware if selling a high value item…. Like say a vintage watch.

Who would buy that old electronic rubbish anyway
.
 
Posts
2,067
Likes
4,210
We believe you that it occurred but I'm pretty sure we are all flabbergasted that something like this could even happen in this day and age and that it really happened as stated. Like, the McDonald's hot coffee lawsuit wasn't actually frivolous but that's how it's portrayed in most cases.

Who the hell thinks this should be ok? Some ivory tower politician in Brussels? It's like people who write software and you can tell that they never actually tried to use it.
 
Posts
867
Likes
1,669
Weird as i had a winning bid last december on an item, seller accepted but cancelled a day later ; item lost or damaged. Few weeks later it was listed again by the same seller, so i started a case with ebay. They did absolutely nothing about it, stating only " they would take action against the seller but could not disclose what it was" .
T
he second time on auction it was won by a zero feedback buyer, and relisted the next day again. So he was bidding on his own item or the zero feedback bidder was a fraud ? Again i reported this to ebay and i got the same, non specific answer so i gave up on it.

As per the pics below I recently had an offer accepted for an Omega box - one that I have fruitlessly sought for a long time. I was delighted to win the auction but within 24 hours the seller had cancelled the transaction and resold the box for a higher price. I was really peeved - I’ve been on eBay since 2003 and I try to treat other eBay members fairly. I complained to eBay and they said they’d take appropriate action but who knows what action they took (if any). Obviously, I wouldn’t pursue the seller but there should be some deterrent where sellers cancel transactions for no legitimate reason other than to resell for a higher price. By the way when I asked the seller why he had cancelled he told me that he had decided to keep the box!!
 
Posts
572
Likes
754
Lawyer here dealing with cross border enforcement of judgments. 1. Whilst Rome 1 is an EU regulation, it replaces a convention to the same effect and, likely, English common law on governing laws of contract would determine that German law applied. 2. German judgments aren’t enforceable as of right in England, so I’m a bit mystified what the bailiffs were doing. The article doesn’t say, but before the bailiffs went around, I would have thought you’d have to take two further steps: first start English proceedings leading to summary judgment based on the German judgment and second obtain an order for the seizure of goods to satisfy that judgment. There’s undoubtedly a lot more to this than two rather poor tabloid articles.