Omega Speedmaster reduced or Hamilton intra-matic

Posts

701

Likes

2,579

redzer007

·Jul 17, 2020

Go and try on a speedmaster professional (and/or a FOIS) as well, yes you will need to increase your budget but it may be where you end up. A FOIS sits between reduced and professional size wize.

That said, if I were to choose one of these 2, its the Hammy all day for me.

 

Posts

16,307

Likes

44,939

JwRosenthal

·Jul 17, 2020

Scarecrow Boat

The same one that I know of (from the vintage date you showed me)? I wish I lived closer. All of the ones local to me that I know of are closed.

Yup- them. But I went in before covid- life seems to have stopped March 14th.

 

Posts

11,951

Likes

39,321

abrod520

·Jul 17, 2020

In late to cast my vote for the Hamilton

 

K

Posts

1,443

Likes

3,809

killer67

·Jul 17, 2020

Put me down for the Intramatic

 

Posts

521

Likes

788

OmegaP99

·Jul 17, 2020

Badwolf

I love my reduced, I think white really suits it.

That's giving me Baby Alaska Project vibes. Looks great!

 

Posts

1,049

Likes

6,266

RI Omega Fan

·Jul 17, 2020

My pick: the Hamilton.

 

Posts

2,549

Likes

3,412

Donn Chambers

·Jul 18, 2020

Get the Hamilton. While the Speedy Reduced has some love on this forum (for whatever reason), the movement in it is a big drawback. Many watchmakers will not touch it because of the modular design, which means you may have to send it back to Omega for service and pay more.

The Hamilton uses a very robust and easily serviced Valjoux movement. It’s just better than the one in the Omega.

Plus, even though they are the same price, the Omega is at least 20 years old and who knows the service history. The Hamilton is new (or newish) and you can enjoy it for years before you need a service. Don’t be surprised if the Omega gives you problems within a year if you buy it.

 

Posts

5,401

Likes

18,815

pdxleaf

·Jul 18, 2020·So on and so on and scoobie doobie doo

Donn Chambers

Get the Hamilton. While the Speedy Reduced has some love on this forum (for whatever reason), the movement in it is a big drawback. Many watchmakers will not touch it because of the modular design, which means you may have to send it back to Omega for service and pay more.

The Hamilton uses a very robust and easily serviced Valjoux movement. It’s just better than the one in the Omega.

Agree and happy to see the Hamilton love. One thing to note is that the 3520.50 triple date i mentioned earlier has a Valjoux 7751 based movement, which is one reason I had chosen it over the reduced ( similar to your reasoning here.) While the 3520.50 is likely more than 1500 and is climbing in cost, I think a decent one can still be found between 1500 and 2000 and it is near the size of the reduced.

Still, not necessarily advocating one over the other.

 

Posts

3,428

Likes

8,620

MRC

·Jul 18, 2020

Donn Chambers

While the Speedy Reduced has some love on this forum (for whatever reason),

More than a half-century back I used to correspond regularly with an uncle -- by handwritten letter, try that nowadays! He wanted to buy a new car and had listed all his candidates and rated their qualities with a comprehensive scoring system. Top score on the list was a VW Beetle, bottom of the list was a Bond Equipe (you may need to look this one up). His actual purchase?

The Bond -- in fact he bought another later. His explanation? You don't get to chose who you fall in love with. You just do.

 

H

Posts

9

Likes

19

Hxt1

·Aug 6, 2020

Scarecrow Boat

Here is a side by side of the Pro vs Reduced. Every thread can always use more photos lol

I love the reduced! Until I see a pro or moon watch. I have an 1168 bracelet just itching to be strapped to a vintage or beat speedy. Arrrrrgh!!!

 

Posts

385

Likes

3,407

kaapstadflaneur

·Aug 8, 2020

My vote is for the Hamilton. I've owned (and sold) both at various points. I regret selling the Hamilton, not the Reduced.

 

Posts

216

Likes

1,431

NikolShep

·Aug 8, 2020

I am not an owner, but would choose Hamilton because:
1) more substantial on my 20-cm wrist (see below)!
2) has date;
3) can be bought new;
4) more aesthetically pleasing;
5) more going on on the dial. I would probably go for Panda variation (looks more classy and retro to me vs. reverse Panda OP posted and I post here).
The only disadvantage to me would be the ability to time up to 30-min (Hamilton)

vs. 12-hr intervals.

 

Posts

8,095

Likes

58,217

TexOmega

·Aug 8, 2020

Hamilton, if these are the two choices.

 

Posts

36

Likes

51

GT_Aventus

·Jul 4, 2022

I like the Hamilton dial, but the intra-matic has a thick unrefined case design with an all-polish finish that makes it look cheap (like a $250 Seiko or Tissot). Very blocky case and with a large unattractive crown and lazy milanese strap option rather than an integrated end-link design. The random date at the bottom doesn't make it any better.

 

Posts

3,428

Likes

8,620

MRC

·Jul 4, 2022

GT_Aventus

. The random date at the bottom doesn't make it any better.

That's not a random date Hamilton, this is a random date Hamilton"