Yes, this happened to me. I was pesturing my wife for years with watch pictures, trying to get her to pick out a watch. (She didn't enjoy it, but I was relentless/obsessive.)
Finally, after begging her to look at just a few more (hundreds) of pictures, she scrolled past one and said, "Oh, I like this!"
It was a gold Daytona. When I told her the cost she rejected it. (She's okay with me spending money on a watch for myself but doesn't want an expensive watch for herself.)
Yes, it surprised me. But the Daytona did what hundreds of other watches couldn't do.
She ultimately chose a Constellation that I bought for myself originally, which she calls her "piepan." I later got her into my AD to look at pre-owned watches, mostly Longines and Datejusts and day-dates, and she saw a Cartier that she liked. She was surprised by it but really liked it on her wrist. So happy ending.