Community Stories

Omega Seamaster 1958, cal 520. Worth?

lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
Omega Seamaster 1958 cal 520

I want to buy my first Seamaster and I would like to know what you think about this watch because I am not a specialist in the field.
In the description the seller says he changed the case, what do you think?
The price of 1000$ seems a bit high, but how much should I negotiate?
I’ll put the link here for full description and photos: https://www.chrono24.com/search/ind...58&searchexplain=true&sortorder=1&watchTypes=

With thanks,
Bogdan
 
FD3266FC-1747-4B80-86C2-4E9CCEB097EB.png 862BAFC9-F864-4940-9125-A944AB63D324.png
timecube
Posts
614
Likes
836
Unlike the other watches on that site, this listing does NOT show the movement.
It would be nice to see the movement, to know what it really is (and what kind of condition it's in).
 
Shabbaz
Posts
4,997
Likes
18,549
When i open the link i cant see the watch. Anyway, pass. Not worth it.
 
Shabbaz
Posts
4,997
Likes
18,549
Ah. I found it. Run. And never look back. Stay around here and look at the sales forum.
 
lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
timecube timecube
Unlike the other watches on that site, this listing does NOT show the movement.
It would be nice to see the movement, to know what it really is (and what kind of condition it's in).
 
5C9287FE-659C-4A7C-A0A9-759A71742589.png
padders
Posts
10,446
Likes
16,336
The movement number later than 1958. That is more like 1960. He openly accepts it is a Franken with a replaced case. Steer clear.
 
Steve1haggart
Posts
1,040
Likes
1,308
nice watch. dial looks clean ,movement looks ok as for the price pass its worth only half that.

try making them an offer only pay what you think the watch is worth to you .
 
lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
Shabbaz Shabbaz
Ah. I found it. Run. And never look back. Stay around here and look at the sales forum.
Thank you for the advice.
 
STANDY
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
Dealer price. $300+ more than you would pay.

I would keep my money and find a nicer dial, hand set and a case style with thicker lugs.
$1000 should get you a better example with a bit of time and knowledge gained in that time
 
Edward53
Posts
3,133
Likes
5,565
You can do WAY better for that money! For $1K I would expect a perfect example, automatic, and with a good BOR bracelet.

Chrono24 is not the friend of the new buyer....
 
lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
Edward53 Edward53
You can do WAY better for that money! For $1K I would expect a perfect example, automatic, and with a good BOR bracelet.

Chrono24 is not the friend of the new buyer....
Can you tell me a better site?
 
Edward53
Posts
3,133
Likes
5,565
lilwine lilwine
Can you tell me a better site?

I can tell you two. One is the Private Sales forum here. The other is ebay - but it is necessary to have some knowledge first. Patience is also essential!
 
Edward53
Posts
3,133
Likes
5,565
If you go down the ebay route, some advice:
1. Decide on one or two models that you like and study them intensively. Be aware that as you learn more, your taste may change!
2. Don't waste your time with business sellers.
3. Don't waste your time with Buy It Now listings.
4. Don't look for a cheap watch that needs work doing. Look for one that appears all original and in good condition.
We were all beginners once and we all understand the difficulty and stress in finding that first vintage Omega. If you are careful and patient, you will find one to enjoy for years to come.
 
lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
Edward53 Edward53
If you go down the ebay route, some advice:
1. Decide on one or two models that you like and study them intensively. Be aware that as you learn more, your taste may change!
2. Don't waste your time with business sellers.
3. Don't waste your time with Buy It Now listings.
4. Don't look for a cheap watch that needs work doing. Look for one that appears all original and in good condition.
We were all beginners once and we all understand the difficulty and stress in finding that first vintage Omega. If you are careful and patient, you will find one to enjoy for years to come.
Thank you for your helpful tips and time. 😀
 
Shabbaz
Posts
4,997
Likes
18,549
There are also a lot of online auctions. You can find them on sites like the salesroom, etc. I would say a watch like yours would fetch not more than EUR 350/400 on open auction. I bought dozens of seamasters in way better condition for under EUR 500. @Edward53 is giving you some very good advice. Focus on a couple of models and start there. If in doubt, post here. People will help you. Good luck!
 
Rochete
Posts
1,232
Likes
5,682
I think that one could easily fetch around €500 in open auction, being a 50s Seamaster in "nice" condition. Most people couldn't care less that it's a franken. $1000 is outrageous.
 
Shabbaz
Posts
4,997
Likes
18,549
Rochete Rochete
I think that one could easily fetch around €500 in open auction, being a 50s Seamaster in "nice" condition. Most people couldn't care less that it's a franken. $1000 is outrageous.
It's a 33mm watch. Small market for these. But 500? Maybe. You never know. Similar 33mm's i've sold were very difficult to sell for that kind of money. Especially because you can buy a nice 34/35mm for the same price.
 
lilwine
Posts
32
Likes
15
Shabbaz Shabbaz
There are also a lot of online auctions. You can find them on sites like the salesroom, etc. I would say a watch like yours would fetch not more than EUR 350/400 on open auction. I bought dozens of seamasters in way better condition for under EUR 500. @Edward53 is giving you some very good advice. Focus on a couple of models and start there. If in doubt, post here. People will help you. Good luck!
Thank you very much!
 
1 More Post...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

Giovanni2023

"Pre-Seamaster" (1958, Caliber Ω 470, 34.5mm)?

Giovanni2023 Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Giovanni2023
Giovanni2023
Posts
7
Views
3K
JBSMP

1958 Omega Seamaster 520 Cal

JBSMP Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
jantjewgm
jantjewgm
Posts
6
Views
3K
A

Omega Seamaster 1958 Cal.471

aquirlan Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Dan S
Dan S
Posts
8
Views
7K
1

Purchasing a Vintage seamaster 1958 cal 420 need help!

13tony_boy Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
1
13tony_boy
Posts
11
Views
2K
R

SEAMASTER 1958- CAL 501 - NEED HELP - REDIAL

rccbeber Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
ConElPueblo
ConElPueblo
Posts
15
Views
2K
V

Vintage Seamaster 1958 spare part & Omega Geneve

Vipcanabis Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
padders
padders
Posts
7
Views
1K