I found your logic to be pretty ridiculous, and even more so for your tone. You seem to indicate that I should not have the right to return it, and doing so is harming others.
Here're my responses:
1. Right to return is a well established set of rules that is applicable for all merchandise. You logic can be applied to any goods we purchase at any store. Do you question yourself before you return things to Costco/Amazon?
2. At my particular AD, the return policy is that within 5 days, if no surface damage and subject to inspection/evaluation, the watch can be returned or exchanged. This policy is written on the invoice, and I'm following the rules.
3. I have not worn the watch. Case back stick is not removed. The watch has been sitting in the pouch offered by the AD with a divider separating the case back and bracelet. And I return it the 2nd day after purchase. The AD offered the exchange exactly because of that: there's no sign of usage.
4. I am curious about how they handle returned watches. As a matter of fact, that is my suspicion that I may have got one of that. How do you know the one I purchased at first is not one that's returned by others? And if so do I have the right to return it?
5. I trust that AD and Omega has set rules and processes to handle returned goods and what standard they need to follow to sell it as new or used. This is not a concern that the customer should burden.
6. People's perspectives and tolerance are different. I may not like this particular aspect, but others may be totally ok with it or even prefer it.
7. Ultimately, it is Omega's manufacturing process that created this variance, that some customer may not like it. Why in your twisted logic it's ok for Omega to sell things that appear to have a loose standard, but not ok for customer to notice it?
8. All watches in display at any AD are subject to inspection/handling by potential customers. My AD allowed me to put it on the wrist, and removed the plastic wrap so that I can feel how sharp the case is. If you are saying you are only happy to buy a watch that has never been touched by anybody else, man, you are in worse OCD than I am.