I've not really been following this thread but I do recognise his user name. I'm pretty sure he sells a reasonable amount of watches and parts.
Never dealt with him though so no idea on the legitimacy of his stock, or his selling practises.
The seller's conduct is shameful, but what also disturbs me is that the quality of the re-dials is getting to the point where multiple people have to weigh in as detectives to determine authenticity. Agonizing over whether parts of your watch are fake takes a little fun out of the whole process.
There is a large gap between the minute track, and the edge of the dial
