I don’t know which I like better..

Posts
21
Likes
37
I am so satisfied with these 2 that I don’t know which one I would pick. What would be your choice?
 
Posts
402
Likes
766
The Speedmaster speaks to me, but I am biased and have one. Always wanted one.
If you like both, which one would you find more practical? Do you want a chronograph or a date window?
 
Posts
1,069
Likes
2,166
Doesn't matter which you choose first because you'll eventually go back for the other.
 
Posts
3,819
Likes
16,168
the Seamaster, I think its a nicer watch... besides the Speedy is running fast.
 
Posts
9,985
Likes
56,690
Both are classics and you can’t go wrong with either, but the Seamaster is more watch for the money.
 
Posts
3,417
Likes
9,047
Speedmaster. But I’m biased, I have a Submariner, a real dive watch 👍
 
Posts
829
Likes
1,417
Does it really matter? You’re going to end up buying both anyway. 😁

For some reason the Seamaster looks really big next to the Speedy in that picture. If you can only buy one, get the Seamaster.
 
Posts
6,383
Likes
21,752
If you don't get the speedy you'll burn your toast and won't know when it's time to pick up the pizza. There's hundreds other uses for those pushers. You'll never use the helium valve.
 
Posts
229
Likes
1,768
Whatever makes you fall in love... On the practical side: the seamaster is more of a beater watch. If you like doing sports (any sport pretty much), the Seamaster can take it all.
 
Posts
35,345
Likes
39,723
I love that Seamaster its one of the best divers on the market and even as a Speedy fan I’d be using it a lot
 
Posts
2,833
Likes
3,881
Seamaster for me. Albeit a touch biased as bought that exact version back in October.

I tried the chronograph version of the Seamaster but it didn’t feel as nice on, as it was a fair bit thicker and heavier. Lovely looking thing with the ceramic push buttons, but just not meant to be.
 
Posts
1,799
Likes
3,487
As the saying goes: "it all depends"...
If you're going to be around or in water a lot, pick the Seamaster. It also doesn't have pushers that can get knocked off if you're into adventure sports.
If you fancy a sports chronograph for tracking elapsed time, with a dose of spacefaring heritage thrown in, pick the Speedmaster.
IMHO the Seamaster is a bit more versatile with regards to matching with clothes. Looks good with shorts and polo shirt, or a tux (ask James Bond).
But as others have said, you'll end up getting both one day...