Community Stories

Fratello Watches shooting themselves in the foot

CameronD
Posts
347
Likes
2,455
Interesting essay on "budget" watches with a condescending article that generated over 250 mostly unfavorable comments.

https://www.fratellowatches.com/why-budget-mechanical-watches-dont-make-sense/

Than a follow on article that generated even more heat on the writer.

https://www.fratellowatches.com/let-me-revisit-that-why-budget-mechanical-watches-dont-make-sense/

Don't understand how a watch blog could consider a watch under 1000 Euro's to be a budget watch. For some maybe, but for many, that is an aspirational number. Also considering that many people become involved in this hobby via entryway watches, for me it was the original Gshock and Swatches.

The downside is, it seems that maybe, Fratello Watches is headed in the same direction as Hodinkee - focusing on super high-end watches and related ad's to go along with them.

Thoughts?
 
Fish70
Posts
1,134
Likes
13,464
I have nothing to add other than it is a dumb take.
 
Larry S
Posts
13,180
Likes
52,375
Wow….Can’t fix stupid.
 
eugeneandresson
Posts
5,048
Likes
15,524
CameronD CameronD
Thoughts?

Buy what you like, for your own reasons. Who gives a hoot about another persons opinions on that matter? Life is too short…
 
Jones in LA
Posts
5,307
Likes
49,339
After reading the header for the second article, I'm relieved to know I'm Special.
 
Scooterino36
Posts
896
Likes
2,809
The writer seems to take specific issue with the mechanical movement being tossed and replaced at service for watches in the general sub $1000 range.

Calling a Sub $1000 watch a "budget" watch, on a watch website isn't exactly controversial in this hobby, regardless of anyone's personal opinion.
I'm genuinely confused why so many people are triggered by this.
 
Foo2rama
Posts
17,811
Likes
27,007
Lol I got bad news about watches getting movements replaced and some major brands.
 
140dave
Posts
1,923
Likes
9,322
Scooterino36 Scooterino36
Calling a Sub $1000 watch a "budget" watch, on a watch website isn't exactly controversial in this hobby, regardless of anyone's personal opinion.
I'm genuinely confused why so many people are triggered by this.
Agree. I think this may be more a tell of the age demographics that frequent Fratello. Younger group would be my guess.
 
Faz
Posts
3,724
Likes
22,431
I managed to get through the utterly superficial and insignificant “article”. I didn’t learn anything other than they need to write something on their site. Anything.
 
Tony C.
Posts
7,808
Likes
27,136
Omegafanman Omegafanman
Lots of fun to be had helping people choose and select watches whatever their budget. And for some £100 is a lot to spend on a watch. Being able to pay your own way and sticking to your own priorities and budget is something to be respected and encouraged more these days.

Agreed, and beyond that, given some knowledge, and patience, it is possible to purchase superb vintage watches for under $1,000.

It is myopic to the extreme to imagine that >$1k vintage watches are necessarily superior to those which cost less.
 
Togri v. 2.0
Posts
2,561
Likes
11,787
Do I agree with the writer? Not really. Does the article make my blood boil? Nein. Would I rather read another article explaining why the 14270 Explorer is the best everyday watch? Nooo. Would I rather read yet another article on a random $2000 dollar watch being called modern and value for money because it had a ceramic bezel and 60 hours of power reserve? #%£€ off

It’s a watch blog. They cover watches not world altering events. They need to write about something 😀😀
Edited:
 
Aroxx
Posts
2,774
Likes
13,269
I don't get the outrage. It's just like, some guys opinion, man. I didn't care enough to read the second rebuttal piece. I don't share the same concern about having a movement swapped out. From an economics perspective he's got a bit of a point. My Hamilton Khaki Field Automatic is due for a service and running a tad slow. I bought it for about $350. That's close to what a service will cost. Don't wanna do it. Shoot, should I just buy a new one? If I could swap a movement for $50-$100 that would be fine by me. Seems a bit wasteful though. I wonder what they do with the old movement.

I love that there are lots of budget friendly, entry-level mechanicals for people to enjoy. That's where I started with an Orient and the Hamilton. But once it gets to the servicing game they kinda do make less sense than a quartz in the long haul. Some would be cheaper to just buy the same watch new again than to service it.

upload_2023-6-24_21-37-25.gif
 
Braindrain
Posts
751
Likes
1,336
Yeah, I don't get where all the hate is coming from.

As collectors, we've all been down that path. Buying a cheapie mechanical (as a beater or whatnot) and deciding, if and when the point comes, whether to pay the $ for a full service (which costs as much or more than what you paid for the watch) or just buy a new one.

Author suggests, to avoid that scenario, one might consider a quartz. Ok, I get that.

In the end, it's a decision that has to be made. He had a couple of points, but the article wasn't meant to be comprehensive. It just reflects his POV.
 
DoctorEvil
Posts
1,545
Likes
2,987
Everyone's entitled to an opinion and the writer of the original Fratello article did say that he's a bit of a romantic who likes the idea of a hand made work of art being disassembled and lovingly cleaned before being put back together. So the idea of the whole watch movement being taken out and replaced would just go against everything that he loves about mechanicals. From a purely economic perspective, I disagree with the author of the Fratello article as I think that low cost mechanicals can still be economically viable. Let's just say that a quartz watch battery needs to be replaced every 2 years and that the total cost of that would be like $20 a pop. If a cheap mechanical watch has a generic movement like a Miyota that costs something like $80 to purchase and that dies after say 10 years, then replacing that movement would be akin to the cost of all the battery changes combined. So, the maintenance cost of the quartz watch and the cheap mechanical would be essentially the same. As another example, let's just say that my expensive Omega needs to be serviced every 10 years or so and that costs $500-$600 (assuming that I take it back to Swatch). That's still akin to buying a brand new low cost mechanical watch every 10 years.
 
JimInOz
Posts
16,867
Likes
35,355
DoctorEvil DoctorEvil
.......... that costs $500-$600 (assuming that I take it back to Swatch)......

Omega's price today for servicing a basic mechanical Omega starts at AUD$1060. It's been a long time since it was about five or six hundred.
🙁
 
DoctorEvil
Posts
1,545
Likes
2,987
JimInOz JimInOz
Omega's price today for servicing a basic mechanical Omega starts at AUD$1060. It's been a long time since it was about five or six hundred.
🙁
I meant USD. However, I get your point. The last time I serviced my SMP in 2017, it cost me just AUD$800. Prices have definitely gone up since then.
 
Omegafanman
Posts
4,679
Likes
17,740
Tony C. Tony C.
Agreed, and beyond that, given some knowledge, and patience, it is possible to purchase superb vintage watches for under $1,000.

It is myopic to the extreme to imagine that >$1k vintage watches are necessarily superior to those which cost less.

This 1970 Certina Bristol I bought from @Franz for €180 for example. I think the service (which it did not need :0) Cost about £105 and gave me a 12 month warranty. I have gifted this to someone and it should serve them happily for many years to come / they love owning their first vintage watch and it did not break the bank.
.
 
FCE33F3B-D04E-4E14-9722-DF6BB4657420.jpeg 1BD4324B-AAFD-4142-BBEE-4CB651DF6ACB.jpeg BB2AF3FB-66A3-492C-8285-834586B006E0.jpeg
itsjustausername
Posts
352
Likes
1,421
As an expat in The Netherlands, I see this Fratello fracas in the context of the local culture. Bluntly stating your opinion is something the Dutch excel at and pride themselves on. Add a dash of clickbait, and here we are!
 
5 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

Robert-Jan

Event Report – OMEGA X Fratello Watches Speedy Tuesday Event in Bienne

Robert-Jan Modern Omega Watches
Just Livin
Just Livin
Posts
35
Views
7K
Robert-Jan

Invitation: OMEGA x Fratello Watches Speedy Tuesday Event At The OMEGA Museum in Bienne

Robert-Jan Modern Omega Watches
Moppel
Moppel
Posts
6
Views
2K