Community Stories

Forstner 1450 bracelet sneak peek

vlaspri
Posts
368
Likes
253
Dear OF members,

A couple days ago Forstner posted pictures via their IG about their upcoming 1450 look alike bracelet with solid 19/20mm end links, removable by screws links, updated clasp and two finish options (the polished edge or central links will look pretty strange on this one I think).

What are your thoughts on this one?

55F5371D-60C9-43F6-909A-337B4671B806.jpeg 1CBA0C1C-EC55-46E4-909C-42868EDEDB6F.jpeg
 
wagudc
Posts
4,817
Likes
12,197
I get the bracelets modeled after the flatlinks. They are pretty generic in a way, but to copy a unique Omega model and advertise it under the same name seems wrong. Imagine an homage Submariner called the 5513.
 
texasmade
Posts
2,645
Likes
2,960
Forstner and US use the Omega names because it's easier for us to remember. Imagine the 1450 or 1171 being called rounded solid links or rounded hollow links. People would need to go look it up whereas calling it a 1450 or 1171, most people already know what you're referring to.
 
wagudc
Posts
4,817
Likes
12,197
texasmade texasmade
Forstner and US use the Omega names because it's easier for us to remember. People would need to go look it up whereas calling it a 1450 or 1171, most people already know what you're referring to.

I suppose I am questioning of copying the products in the first place. Especially the 1171 which is still available from Omega.
 
texasmade
Posts
2,645
Likes
2,960
wagudc wagudc
I suppose I am questioning of copying the products in the first place. Especially the 1171 which is still available from Omega.
Cheaper alternative or not available. Omega bracelets are like at least $500 whereas US is less than $100 and Forstner is like $150.

1450 isn't made any more and Omega doesn't have a flat link for sale for the FOIS. The 20mm A11 flat link only works on the new Speedmaster cases, supposedly.
 
zwjk
Posts
295
Likes
387
wagudc wagudc
I suppose I am questioning of copying the products in the first place. Especially the 1171 which is still available from Omega.

As an example, not everyone can afford to buy a 1039 for $2.5k.

Forstner is offering a decent alternative for less than 10% of the original. I was a skeptic at first but I just received mine and it’s worth every dollar.

The only alternative that was available previously was one from eBay for around $600 and the end links didn’t even fit the case.
 
wagudc
Posts
4,817
Likes
12,197
zwjk zwjk
As an example, not everyone can afford to buy a 1039 for $2.5k.

Forstner is offering a decent alternative for less than 10% of the original. I was a skeptic at first but I just received mine and it’s worth every dollar.

The only alternative that was available previously was one from eBay for around $600 and the end links didn’t even fit the case.

I have no issue with the flatlinks, see my first post in this thread.
 
cvalue13
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,018
texasmade texasmade
Forstner and US use the Omega names because it's easier for us to remember. Imagine the 1450 or 1171 being called rounded solid links or rounded hollow links. People would need to go look it up whereas calling it a 1450 or 1171, most people already know what you're referring to.

the paragraph above would be *gold* to an IP/TM lawyer representing Omega on this
 
cvalue13
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,018
zwjk zwjk
As an example, not everyone can afford to buy a 1039 for $2.5k.

Forstner is offering a decent alternative for less than 10% of the original. I was a skeptic at first but I just received mine and it’s worth every dollar.

The only alternative that was available previously was one from eBay for around $600 and the end links didn’t even fit the case.


Me thinks you’re confusing what you like with what is legal

I made that mistake once in Reno around ‘98, and I’ve not been back to California since
 
Pazzo
Posts
795
Likes
1,157
cvalue13 cvalue13
Me thinks you’re confusing what you like with what is legal

I made that mistake once in Reno around ‘98, and I’ve not been back to California since

I wonder what that "mistake" was. ... 😀
 
Pazzo
Posts
795
Likes
1,157
cvalue13 cvalue13
the paragraph above would be *gold* to an IP/TM lawyer representing Omega on this

I don't think that there's Omega stamped on any of the products coming from both mentioned companies.
 
zwjk
Posts
295
Likes
387
cvalue13 cvalue13
Me thinks you’re confusing what you like with what is legal

I made that mistake once in Reno around ‘98, and I’ve not been back to California since

Please elaborate as I am curious. AFAIK, the design of the Forstner flat link is nothing like the original 1039. Is this still an issue?
 
zwjk
Posts
295
Likes
387
wagudc wagudc
I have no issue with the flatlinks, see my first post in this thread.

I stand corrected!
 
cvalue13
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,018
wagudc wagudc
Imagine an homage Submariner called the 5513.

I do think the forum will need to eventually confront its strict rule against ‘homage’ watches as relates to the forum’s now growing enthusiasm for ‘homage’ watch parts such as these.

The JBs were a different thing; the flatlink has ventured into another thing (in my view**), while these new offerings appear to be going unarguably elbow deep.

I don’t begrudge the nice folks behind these companies, in the same way I can’t begrudge the folks who make homage watches. Doesn’t mean I should support the products that appear to run afoul of the same principles behind the forum rules against supporting homage “watches.”

**to wit, on another thread, one of these company’s appeared to gave ‘wink-wink, nudge-nudge’ reasons for why the flatlink is not available from their non-U.S. location
 
cvalue13
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,018
zwjk zwjk
As an example, not everyone can afford to buy a 1039 for $2.5k.

Forstner is offering a decent alternative for less than 10% of the original. I was a skeptic at first but I just received mine and it’s worth every dollar.

The only alternative that was available previously was one from eBay for around $600 and the end links didn’t even fit the case.


I hope you’ll not find the following rhetorical device too offensive or personal, but instead only a part of a conversation worth taking seriously:

“As an example, not everyone can afford to buy a [Submariner 16610] for [$10K].

[Steinhart] is offering a decent alternative for less than 10% of the original. I was a skeptic at first but I just received mine and it’s worth every dollar.

The only alternative that was available previously was one from eBay for around [$6000] and [it was only that cheap because it was a bad example].”
 
RI Omega Fan
Posts
1,085
Likes
6,498
We all seem to love Uncle Seiko bracelets and straps - I have four (so far!) - as well as Forstner products. The merits of each have been discussed at great length on a lot of threads.

But having said that, this forum recently jumped all over a guy who made a really good reproduction DON bezel, even though, if I remember correctly, he claimed it was a one-off and he had no intention to sell them. Is there really much difference between repro bezels and bracelets? Where is the line drawn?
 
vlaspri
Posts
368
Likes
253
wagudc wagudc
I suppose I am questioning of copying the products in the first place. Especially the 1171 which is still available from Omega.
1171 is still available from Omega?! Now this is interesting. Ordering through Omega boutiques and dealers or there’s any other way to have it?
 
eugeneandresson
Posts
5,071
Likes
15,650
RI Omega Fan RI Omega Fan
But having said that, this forum recently jumped all over a guy who made a really good reproduction DON bezel, even though, if I remember correctly, he claimed it was a one-off and he had no intention to sell them.

He is selling them though. And his magic dinstinguishable trick is UV reactivity, which I find great. He is not trying to deceive, giving an easy tell, and satisfying the pedant urge to dismiss any differences to vintage ones that we all love to spot. But I don't want to open up this kettle of fish ...
 
JwRosenthal
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,994
RI Omega Fan RI Omega Fan
We all seem to love Uncle Seiko bracelets and straps - I have four (so far!) - as well as Forstner products. The merits of each have been discussed at great length on a lot of threads.

But having said that, this forum recently jumped all over a guy who made a really good reproduction DON bezel, even though, if I remember correctly, he claimed it was a one-off and he had no intention to sell them. Is there really much difference between repro bezels and bracelets? Where is the line drawn?
Same with a member who proposed having repro bezels made for the SM120- which is a long NLA part and rarer than hens teeth.
I have no issue with Forstner reissuing the flatlink as JBC made flatlink bracelets (and Forstner owns the name rights to JBC now) just like the made the Komfit.
Jjustification can be made for US making the Holzer and his flatlink- neither are currently available from any other maker in that style (other than Forstner and it’s a different design).
Aftermarket bracelets have been a part of horology since the wrist watch hit the market- in fact it was the aftermarket that existed before they became in house offerings (Gay Freres, Bonklip, JBC, Kreisler).

I do agree that calling them by their Omega number gets into grey territory.
 
M'Bob
Posts
7,177
Likes
23,253
RI Omega Fan RI Omega Fan
Is there really much difference between repro bezels and bracelets? Where is the line drawn?

For me the line is when the mostly uninformed can easily distinguish the difference.
 
91 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

fskywalker

Forstner 1450 / Flat Link Bracelet Endlinks for Rolex Explorer 1 / Omega Aqua Terra 42 MM

fskywalker Watch Parts and Accessories For Sale
fskywalker
fskywalker
Posts
10
Views
954
Lu..

anybody install an OEM clasp on Forstner 1450 bracelet

Lu.. Modern Omega Watches
P
piumach
Posts
3
Views
3K
C

Is this happening to your Forstner 1450 bracelet?

crumbsnatcher74 Modern Omega Watches
ae86guy
ae86guy
Posts
66
Views
34K
uvalaw2005

20mm Forstner 1450 President Bracelet for Omega Speedmaster 3861

uvalaw2005 Watch Parts and Accessories For Sale
uvalaw2005
uvalaw2005
Posts
1
Views
2K
keisuke_z

Custom polishing outer links on a Forstner 1450

keisuke_z Modern Omega Watches
ErichPryde
ErichPryde
Posts
6
Views
3K
DLT222

Omega Forum Forstner Bands Overview & Discount Code for UK & EU ONLY!

DLT222 Watch Parts and Accessories For Sale
DLT222
DLT222
Posts
0
Views
11K