Dinky hits new lows

Posts
896
Likes
3,708

The resulting watch has a bit of a Tudor Ranger look to it combined with a Submariner. The 6-9-12 layout with the date at three reminds me of a Tudor Ranger Date and the black rotating bezel is where the Submariner inspiration kicks in.

Could it be perhaps the price is so high because this one has a rare flat 4 insert... 😁
 
Posts
434
Likes
1,027
I saw this listing referenced in an incredibly optimistic eBay listings for a cheap chrome plated Orvin diver and couldn’t believe that this is actually something they sold.

https://shop.hodinkee.com/products/2828-orvin-diver


The tradition line of stainless divers from Sears were nicely made, and most likely made by Orvin and can be had in the $4-700 range. But these chrome plated watches are bargain basement pieces.

I get that the market for vintage has gone nuts, but this sets the bar so low that I tripped over it.

I saw that too, unreal.
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,981
Could it be perhaps the price is so high because this one has a rare flat 4 insert... 😁
Lol- yes, the famous Oris flat 4, and it has numerals on the dial like a 1016 explorer so it must be worth at least 1/10 of one,
 
Posts
13,465
Likes
52,961
I cannot believe that this thing sold at that number.
 
Posts
3,789
Likes
40,899
I am just so dumbfounded, I will include the picture of the back and article in case they remove it in shame. They compared this to the Tudor ranger and the Seamaster…what the actual fυck?!?!



WHY THIS WATCH MATTERS
This classic diver was made for Sears, Roebuck and Co., a U.S. department store.
THE FULL STORY
An anchor at many American malls of the 20th century, Sears or Sears, Roebuck and Co. should be a name that sounds familiar at least. Orvin on the other hand, may not. Just as with Baylor with Zales, Orvin was an inhouse brand name for some Sears watches. Rather than slap their own name on the dial, these retailers chose to choose something that could be perceived as "fancier" or more reliable at least.

This Orvin is going for more reliability. As a Skin Diver style tool watch, Sears looked to provide their customers with a simple, robust, go-anywhere dive watch in this Orvin. The resulting watch has a bit of a Tudor Ranger look to it combined with a Submariner. The 6-9-12 layout with the date at three reminds me of a Tudor Ranger Date and the black rotating bezel is where the Submariner inspiration kicks in. We also appreciate the minimal text on the dial. Confirming the Sears provenance are case stampings from Sears as well as a US import code on the movement reading "SOX."

We paired this Orvin, or Sears, with our Bedford strap in light grey to keep things simple.
Well, Seamaster and Tudor are Swiss Made, Anti-magnetic, Water-resistant and stainless steel too... Ressemblances are striking indeed 😜😁
 
Posts
3,791
Likes
22,701
Ah it has possible implications to make those cheap divers you can still find not so cheap. I noticed the a few days after that NYT article pointing out cheap obtainable watches and reviving old brands the same 60’s Waltham diver I got for 125 bucks was selling online for 600 plus and it was in very poor condition. Doesn’t mean anyone will pay that but the flippers watch this closely. Kind of a bummer.
It’s called “Trickle up” watchonomics unfortunately. Watch for the plethora of “what’s the value of this Watch” threads for first post members..watch collecting no more. It’s the watch market now.
 
Posts
896
Likes
3,708
I know that I am probably in the minority on this one but I actually don't have a problem with dealers asking above market- albeit this is extreme- given the time and resources they have to allocate towards curating examples they feel is up to there (lower) standards Obviously no one is compelled to purchase any item at these increased prices

My issue is when these dealers knowingly deceive their intended audience. Pictured below is a watch that I assume initially went unsold from another dealer:





Same example was then edited to reduce spotting on the dial and coloring was altered to such a degree that it now appears to be a pink gold example with a two tone dial. It was subsequently relisted and of course sold:

 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,981
I know that I am probably in the minority on this one but I actually don't have a problem with dealers asking above market- albeit this is extreme- given the time and resources they have to allocate towards curating examples they feel is up to there (lower) standards Obviously no one is compelled to purchase any item at these increased prices

My issue is when these dealers knowingly deceive their intended audience. Pictured below is a watch that I assume initially went unsold from another dealer:





Same example was then edited to reduce spotting on the dial and coloring was altered to such a degree that it now appears to be a pink gold example with a two tone dial. It was subsequently relisted and of course sold:

Agreed. I don’t begrudge anyone making a fair living at whatever their trade is- we all need to eat. The assumption is that buying from a reputable dealer will yield a quality product that has been curated and represented honesty- with a guarantee of some sort.
The watch in question here is one that is so below the standards of any reputable dealer that it’s truly shocking. Don’t get me wrong, I love me some cheap divers- but if I saw that Orvin in the glass case at an antique mall with a $150 price tag on it, I would laugh and say they were nuts.
 
Posts
3,791
Likes
22,701
Agreed. I don’t begrudge anyone making a fair living at whatever their trade is- we all need to eat. The assumption is that buying from a reputable dealer will yield a quality product that has been curated and represented honesty- with a guarantee of some sort.
The watch in question here is one that is so below the standards of any reputable dealer that it’s truly shocking. Don’t get me wrong, I love me some cheap divers- but if I saw that Orvin in the glass case at an antique mall with a $150 price tag on it, I would laugh and say they were nuts.
Agree here as well, but what happens if all of a sudden 50 “watch investors” become interested in this watch?
I went through something similar a few months ago with bourbon. After a few articles where written on some whiskey blogs about the scarcity of scotch and the renewed interest in bourbon, the bottle of Blanton’s I was getting at the duty free for $59, raised to $ 149 the week after. Now it’s gone the way of Rolex watches. Unobtainable…unless you’re willing to pay. I suspect that even the most modest vintage sports watches are instantly being affected by everything that’s written about them and instantly available on social media/ internet.

Hyping has always existed but these days, hype has an almost instant and powerful effect.
 
Posts
7,538
Likes
13,921
That Orvin watch was probably $15 or so when sold by Sears back in the 60's. A slight step up from the ubiquitous Timex.

There are many clueless people out there who will believe anything a particular company tells them because said company is looked upon as reliable and honest. Hodinkee is just being dishonest in search of an uninformed buck. That seems to be their business model. I just don't do business with companies like that.
 
Posts
3,563
Likes
24,067
This price inflation is painful. I've finally come to terms with likely never being able to afford an Explorer II. At this rate, I'll soon have to cope with vintage Orvin being out of reach too.
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,981
This price inflation is painful. I've finally come to terms with likely never being able to afford an Explorer II. At this rate, I'll soon have to cope with vintage Orvin being out of reach too.

Friends don’t let friends overpay for cheap chrome plated watches.
 
Posts
434
Likes
1,027
That Orvin watch was probably $15 or so when sold by Sears back in the 60's. A slight step up from the ubiquitous Timex.

In '68 it was $19.99, so yeah, close. That's ~$160 USD in today's money. Regardless of case material, movement, brand, there is undeniably a price to pay for aesthetics. I'm not agreeing with the Hodinkee price because IMO that's gouging. However, they aren't the only online vendor I see with prices that seem a bit high across the board.
 
Posts
5,059
Likes
15,577
On a logarithmic scale the lows are around the same order of magnitude as the travel clock debacle…
 
Posts
10,610
Likes
51,753
I’m not like new to liking watches. Even as a kid I liked them but my first “nice watch” was a quartz movado Visio. I still have it, somewhere. I still don’t consider myself a serious educated collector but moving on from being quite happy with a nice quartz seiko, movado to now appreciating vintage and paying more attention to and appreciation for auto and mechanical watches and purchasing a few watches that cost an amount I used to think people were crazy paying. Mind you I still have no problem buying cheaper things as long as I like them.

I guess what I’m trying to get at is asking if any of you who have been into watch collecting seriously for a decade or longer, have you seen bubbles and bursts? Is where we are at a unique time? It seems many collectibles go through hot and cold periods, some come back from the cold periods some don’t. I have a few revolutionary war things and some kinda ancient Chinese art that have decently seen very hot times then cooled off but it never crossed my mind to sell at the hot times as I don’t have a lot and they are things I really like so why get rid of them. I’m just trying to bring in a couple comparisons but I have no clue if they are relevant. If I had to sell all my watches and only lost a couple hundred I’d be OK with that. As it stands now I think I’d be on the plus side but I only sell things if I want to get something different.

So have there been monetary crashes in the “watch market” historically in the experience of those with such experience.
 
Posts
9,217
Likes
24,053
well, at least that Bedford strap is nice....

....😲 $165?! 😬
 
Posts
897
Likes
2,813
Lol- yes, the famous Oris flat 4, and it has numerals on the dial like a 1016 explorer so it must be worth at least 1/10 of one,

Buyers are willing to pay a premium for an inhouse (Sears) movement. 😁