Daily manually winding an automatic 2500D damage it? (15 winds)

Posts
553
Likes
2,760
I would particularly appreciate Archer’s opinion and anyone else who wants to chime in.

I am inactive at a desk most of the day. The watchmaker at the Omega boutique recommended I give my watch 15 manual winds a day.

Is the 2500D movement designed to handle this? My watch does not have a screw down crown and is a dress Omega DeVille. On some forums people say automatic watches are not designed to be daily wound and this can damage them??
 
Posts
6,748
Likes
12,733
Have you fully wound it (50-60 winds) and then wore it in your daily activity? How long can you go before it runs down and stops? Modern watches in good shape are pretty efficient, maybe you don't really have an issue.
 
Posts
8,999
Likes
46,202
Aside from just putting some wear on the crown, stem, etc., I’m not sure how you could damage the movement. All manual winding accomplishes is to wind up the mainspring which is the same thing that the rotor accomplishes in response to the movement of your body. Whether wound manually or via the rotor, you can’t overwind an automatic watch because there is a slip clutch mechanism which prevents that from occurring.
 
Posts
27,313
Likes
69,665
Unless you are extraordinarily sedentary, there shouldn’t be any need to manually wind the watch each day.

Having said that, if the watch is new or recently serviced, and it is stopping on you, then winding it a little won’t hurt anything.

Cheers, Al
 
Posts
14,087
Likes
40,506
I’d only be winding it manually if your level of activity in a normal day was insufficient to keep it running.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,790
I am, like you, pinned to (the equivalent of) a desk. Absolutely none of my automatics require winding except for the day I put one on to wear for a few days until I wear something else. This includes unidirectional bumpers. I suggest that you don't need to manually wind either.
 
Posts
553
Likes
2,760
My watch has been at Omega boutique who checked my watch. They tested amplitude etc and see attached pic for results. The watch maker tested power reserve by winding watch manually and letting it rest, all ok. They put it on windmill then letting it rest,all ok. The watch maker said the watch power reserve lasted about 50 hours.View attachment 1294643

My issue is that I would wear daily, my constant walking movement in a day was no longer than 25 mins a day. Additionally, I would walk a bit at work and at home but not much at all. Mostly sitting down at work and at home in the day. I would wear watch about 10 hours a day. Over 6 week period after setting watch 69 manual winds the watch never ever stopped if worn every single day.

After 6 weeks I put the watch down on table it stopped after24 hours. The watch maker said it is normal and I need to be more active OR give watch 15 manual winds a day to give it a boost.

Is my watch ok?
 
Posts
553
Likes
2,760
Unless you are extraordinarily sedentary, there shouldn’t be any need to manually wind the watch each day.

Having said that, if the watch is new or recently serviced, and it is stopping on you, then winding it a little won’t hurt anything.

Cheers, Al

Thanks. Please see my comment further down.
 
Posts
14,087
Likes
40,506
Competent watchmakers can fix BROKEN watches. But they can’t fix watches that run down and stop because the owner isn’t active enough. Ten hours a day on the wrist of a person who doesn’t move much, and there will be times when it runs down. An analogy might be that you’ll drive twice as far on a full tank of gas than you will on half a tank.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,790
I never take mine off, even wearing them to bed. Ten hours a day won't cut it.

And, yes, your watch is keeping time quite well, according to that timing analysis!
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,107
The watch maker said it is normal and I need to be more active
I'm generally in the same boat as you and my watchmaker, doctor, and wife (3 separate people though wouldn't that be something if they were all 1 person) would say the same thing, I need to be more active.

I recently bought a standing desk (had one in the office for years) for my house now that I'm working from home and even a few hours standing at the desk or periodically raising/lowering it depending on what I'm working on makes a huge difference. Not only in how I generally feel but also in how much my watch winds. Even just standing at the desk and shifting my weight now and then I tend to move my arms around more and the rotor gets a few rotations.

My advice, if you're able, try and find a way to be more active. I totally get that there are plenty of people with health issues or other situations where that just isn't a realistic option but if it is for you that's going to be the best thing you can do. Outside of that, wind the watch when you notice it's not running, if you're tied to your desk like I am you probably aren't saving lives by having the most precise time on your watch 😀

I also picked up a cheap-ish watchwinder that has multiple settings for rotations per hour. A watch I wear frequently seems to do fine on the winder overnight running at about 25 rotations per hour.

Edit: Nice watch by the way
 
Posts
184
Likes
83
I would particularly appreciate Archer’s opinion and anyone else who wants to chime in.

I am inactive at a desk most of the day. The watchmaker at the Omega boutique recommended I give my watch 15 manual winds a day.

Is the 2500D movement designed to handle this? My watch does not have a screw down crown and is a dress Omega DeVille. On some forums people say automatic watches are not designed to be daily wound and this can damage them??
The automatic watches these days have a bridal on the mainspring that slides inside the mainspring barrel wall. So don't worry about over winding it.
When winding it though, don't wind it on the wrist. When wound on the wrist it puts unnecessary stress & wear on the plates.
Hey, unless I missed it you could get an automatic winder. Put the watch on it over night.
I am retired, & don't travel around & my ETA 2824-2 does not get a charge, so it gets wound, day, date set when I do wear it.
The part that gets most wear is the screw down crown. Right now it is in the drawer, & I wear an old Gruen manual wind.
Cheers! Mike
 
Posts
27,313
Likes
69,665
Thanks. Please see my comment further down.

There's nothing wrong with the watch.
 
Posts
553
Likes
2,760
Thanks guys.

I will just give it a few winds if I am not active that day.

Or will wind if not wearing watch that day
 
Posts
1,813
Likes
9,381
Buy a manual watch, you will have to wind that whether you move or not.